Theorem Polynomial coordinates on an edge coefficient ring
✓ theorem proved

Polynomial coordinates on an edge coefficient ring

Let \(V\) be a vector space over a field \(k\). For a vector \(a\in V\), choose a basis \((e_j)\) of \(V/ka\). The source constructs \[ \operatorname{Sym}_k(V)/(\iota(a)) \simeq\operatorname{Sym}_k(V/ka) \simeq k[X_j]. \] The class of another linear generator \(\iota(v)\) becomes the linear polynomial with the coordinates of \([v]\) in that basis.

For a nonzero root in the finite-dimensional real extended realization, this is the polynomial presentation of its edge coefficient ring.

Specialize now to the real extended realization \(V\), with original root space \(V_0\) and embedding \(i_0:V_0\hookrightarrow V\). Write \(A_{\mathrm{sym}}=\operatorname{Sym}_{\mathbb R}(V)\), and let \(\Phi:A_{\mathrm{sym}}\to A\) be the chosen polynomial coordinate isomorphism. Write \(\lambda(v)=\Phi(\iota(i_0v))\). For a positive root \(a\), set \(r_a=\lambda(a)\) and put \[ E_a=A/(r_a),\qquad \overline A_a=A_{\mathrm{sym}}/(\iota(i_0a)). \] The map \(\psi_a:E_a\to\overline A_a\) induced by \(\Phi^{-1}\) is an algebra isomorphism. For every positive root \(c\), it sends \([\lambda(c)]\) to \([\iota(i_0c)]\). Thus \(E_a\) is a domain and a unique factorization domain. For a positive root \(c\ne a\), its reduced label \([\lambda(c)]\) is prime in \(E_a\).

Relation to the OpenAI notes

Canonical labels for the same principal ideals.

OpenAI notes: The coefficient discussion uses degree-one linear root labels and permits any nonzero real scalar multiple, because only the principal ideal matters. bg:realization.

Lean (primary): The label is the coordinate polynomial of the embedded canonical positive root for the reflection. Its primality and quotient are proved for that actual element. SheafMorphisms:144, Support:1065, ReflectionSchedules:824.

Role in the proof: Multiplying a label by a nonzero field scalar leaves its principal ideal unchanged. The fixed label used by the code therefore presents the same scalar quotient described in the notes.

Proof

Step 1. Apply the root-line quotient isomorphism

The generic linear-quotient theorem at \(P=ka\) gives the first isomorphism. Its formula on generators is \[ [\iota(v)]\longmapsto\iota_{V/ka}([v]). \]

Step 2. Use the chosen quotient-space basis

The symmetric-algebra coordinate isomorphism sends \(\iota_{V/ka}(e_j)\) to \(X_j\). If \([v]=\sum_j c_je_j\), linearity gives \[ [\iota(v)]\longmapsto\sum_j c_jX_j. \] Composing the two algebra isomorphisms is the source's rootQuotientPolynomial.

Step 3. Check degree and nonvanishing

Every \(X_j\) has degree one, so the displayed polynomial is homogeneous of degree one. It is nonzero exactly when at least one \(c_j\) is nonzero, equivalently when \([v]\ne0\), or \(v\notin ka\).

The linear-prime theorem then also proves primality of every surviving reduced linear generator.

Step 4. Specialize to an actual root label

Let \(V\) be the real extended realization and embed a positive root \(a\) from the original root space. The source defines EdgeCoefficient as the symmetric algebra modulo that embedded root's ideal.

It chooses a finite basis of the quotient space and composes the two isomorphisms above, producing edgePolynomial. If \(\dim V=N\) and \(a\ne0\), the quotient space has dimension \(N-1\), so the edge ring has \(N-1\) polynomial variables. Finite-variable polynomial rings over a field are Noetherian unique factorization domains; these coordinates supply those coefficient-ring hypotheses in the local membership argument.

Step 5. Transport the actual polynomial quotient

The algebra isomorphism \(\Phi\) sends the principal ideal generated by \(\iota(i_0a)\) onto that generated by \(r_a\). Therefore it descends to an isomorphism between the two quotients. The source uses the inverse direction: \[ \psi_a:E_a\xrightarrow{\sim}\overline A_a,\qquad \psi_a([f])=[\Phi^{-1}(f)]. \] Well-definedness follows because a difference \(r_ag\) pulls back to \(\iota(i_0a)\Phi^{-1}(g)\). The forward map induced by \(\Phi\) is its inverse.

For another positive root \(c\), the defining coordinate formula gives \[ \psi_a([\lambda(c)])=[\Phi^{-1}(\Phi(\iota(i_0c)))] =[\iota(i_0c)]. \] This is edgeRingEquiv_root. Composing \(\psi_a\) with the symmetric edgePolynomial isomorphism of Step 4 gives polynomial coordinates on \(E_a\), transporting its domain and unique-factorization properties.

Step 6. Transport primality of a reduced positive root

If \(c\ne a\), independence of distinct positive roots gives \(c\notin\mathbb R a\). Injectivity of the embedding gives \(i_0c\notin\mathbb R(i_0a)\).

The linear-prime theorem therefore makes \([\iota(i_0c)]\) prime in \(\overline A_a\). Step 5 identifies it with \(\psi_a([\lambda(c)])\). Algebra isomorphisms preserve prime elements, so \([\lambda(c)]\) is prime in \(E_a\). This proves the source's reducedPolynomialRoot_prime statement.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.EdgeAlgebra.rootQuotientEquiv: ReflectionSchedules.lean:824.

OAI.KLInvariance.EdgeAlgebra.rootQuotientEquiv_mk_ι: ReflectionSchedules.lean:845.

OAI.KLInvariance.EdgeAlgebra.rootQuotientPolynomial: ReflectionSchedules.lean:871.

OAI.KLInvariance.EdgeAlgebra.linear_homogeneous: ReflectionSchedules.lean:861.

OAI.KLInvariance.EdgeAlgebra.reducedRoot_homogeneous: ReflectionSchedules.lean:875.

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.EdgeCoefficient: ReflectionSchedules.lean:930.

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.edgePolynomial: ReflectionSchedules.lean:950.

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.edgeRingEquiv: TerminalKernels.lean:519.

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.edgeRingEquiv_root: TerminalKernels.lean:524.

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.edgeRing_isDomain: TerminalKernels.lean:531.

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.edgeRing_ufm: TerminalKernels.lean:536.

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.reducedPolynomialRoot_prime: TerminalKernels.lean:539.

Used by