Theorem Plane denominators force membership in a free edge-ring target
✓ theorem proved

Plane denominators force membership in a free edge-ring target

Let \(W\) be a finite-generator real Coxeter system, \(A\) its polynomial coefficient algebra from a real basis of the extended realization, and \(a\) a positive root. Write \(\lambda(a)\) for its root polynomial, and put \[ C=A/(\lambda(a)),\qquad \overline r\in C\text{ for the class of }r\in A. \] Let \(N\) have compatible \(A\)- and \(C\)-module actions, and suppose \(N\) is torsion-free over \(C\). Let \(S\subseteq N\) be an \(A\)-submodule whose same-carrier \(C\)-submodule \(S_C\) is free.

Fix \(z\in N\), and assume the following data.

  • A scalar \(c\in A\) satisfies \(\overline c\ne0\) and \(cz\in S\).
  • Every prime element \(\pi\in C\) dividing \(\overline c\) is associated to \(\overline{\lambda(\beta)}\) for some positive root \(\beta\ne a\).
  • For every positive root \(\beta\ne a\), there is \(s\in A\) with \[ s\notin\mathfrak p_{\operatorname{span}\{a,\beta\}}, \qquad sz\in S. \]

Then \(z\in S\).

Relation to the OpenAI notes

Prime divisors of one multiplier organize the local-to-global step.

OpenAI notes: The notes use membership in a free target at height-one primes. Primes avoiding all reduced root labels give the full localized edge module; root primes use the dihedral local comparison. edge:lattice, edge:bound.

Lean (primary): The proof fixes one global multiplier, the correction lift times the outgoing label product. A prime dividing its reduction is associated to a reduced root and receives the corresponding plane witness. A prime not dividing it uses the global multiplier itself. The free-target prime-removal theorem then gives membership. TerminalKernels:992, TerminalKernels:1045.

Role in the proof: The Blueprint follows these two prime cases and checks quotient-ring freeness, torsion-free cancellation, nonzero global multiplication and every local witness before concluding the inclusion.

Proof

Step 1. Pass the global multiplier to the quotient coefficient ring

The root-quotient coordinate theorem identifies \(C\) with a polynomial algebra over \(\mathbb R\), so \(C\) is a unique factorization domain. The compatible actions identify \(cz\) with \(\overline c\,z\).

Thus the first assumption supplies the nonzero global multiplier required by the prime-denominator membership theorem over \(C\), with free target \(S_C\subseteq N\).

Step 2. Produce a local witness for a prime dividing the global multiplier

Let \(\pi\) be prime in \(C\), and first suppose \(\pi\mid\overline c\). Choose \(\beta\ne a\) with \(\pi\sim\overline{\lambda(\beta)}\) by the second assumption. Choose \(s\notin\mathfrak p_{\operatorname{span}\{a,\beta\}}\) with \(sz\in S\) by the third.

The root-factor divisibility theorem gives \[ \overline{\lambda(\beta)}\mid\overline s \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad s\in\mathfrak p_{\operatorname{span}\{a,\beta\}}. \] The right side is false, so the left side is false. Associated elements have the same divisibility relation, hence \(\pi\nmid\overline s\).

Compatibility of actions gives \(\overline s\,z=sz\in S_C\). Thus \(\overline s\) is the required multiplier not divisible by \(\pi\).

Step 3. Treat primes not dividing the global multiplier

If \(\pi\nmid\overline c\), use \(\overline c\) itself. It is not divisible by \(\pi\), and Step 1 gives \(\overline c\,z\in S_C\).

Combining Steps 2–3 yields, for every prime \(\pi\in C\), a multiplier \(d_\pi\) satisfying \[ \pi\nmid d_\pi,\qquad d_\pi z\in S_C. \]

Step 4. Apply prime-denominator membership to the free target

The prime-denominator membership theorem applies: \(C\) is a UFD, \(N\) is torsion-free, \(S_C\) is free and therefore projective, Step 1 gives a nonzero global multiplier, and Steps 2–3 supply the prime witnesses.

Its finite prime-factor removal argument gives \(z\in S_C\). This submodule has the same carrier as \(S\), so \(z\in S\), as asserted.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.mem_of_plane_denominators: TerminalKernels.lean:992.

Used by