Theorem Symmetric-algebra quotients by linear ideals
✓ theorem proved

Symmetric-algebra quotients by linear ideals

Let \(V\) be a vector space over a field \(k\), let \(P\subseteq V\), and let \(I_P\) be its linear ideal in \(A=\operatorname{Sym}_k(V)\). Then \[ A/I_P\simeq\operatorname{Sym}_k(V/P). \] The ideal \(I_P\) is prime, and \[ \iota(v)\in I_P\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad v\in P. \]

Proof

Step 1. Construct the forward map

The map \(Q_P:A\to\operatorname{Sym}_k(V/P)\) sends \(\iota(v)\) to \(\iota([v])\). If \(v\in P\), then \([v]=0\), so this generator maps to zero.

The kernel of \(Q_P\) is an ideal containing all the generators of \(I_P\), hence contains \(I_P\). Therefore \[ F:A/I_P\to\operatorname{Sym}_k(V/P),\qquad [z]\mapsto Q_P(z) \] is a well-defined algebra map.

Step 2. Construct the inverse map on vector generators

The linear map \(v\mapsto[\iota(v)]\in A/I_P\) vanishes on \(P\). It therefore descends to \[ V/P\longrightarrow A/I_P,\qquad [v]\longmapsto[\iota(v)]. \] The symmetric-algebra universal property extends it to an algebra map \(G:\operatorname{Sym}_k(V/P)\to A/I_P\).

Step 3. Verify both composites

On a generator \(\iota([v])\) of \(\operatorname{Sym}_k(V/P)\), \[ FG(\iota([v]))=F([\iota(v)])=\iota([v]). \] On a generator class of \(A/I_P\), \[ GF([\iota(v)])=G(\iota([v]))=[\iota(v)]. \] Every element of a symmetric algebra is a polynomial in its vector generators, and every quotient element has a representative in \(A\). Thus the two algebra-map identities on generators prove \(FG=1\) and \(GF=1\).

This also proves \(I_P=\ker Q_P\): if \(Q_P(z)=0\), then \(F([z])=0\), so the injective map \(F\) gives \([z]=0\).

Step 4. Detect membership of a linear generator

If \(v\in P\), then \(\iota(v)\) is an ideal generator.

Conversely, \(\iota(v)\in I_P\) implies \(\iota([v])=0\) in \(\operatorname{Sym}(V/P)\). If \([v]\ne0\), extend this nonzero vector to a basis and choose a linear functional \(\lambda:V/P\to k\) with \(\lambda([v])\ne0\).

Its extension to the symmetric algebra sends \(\iota([v])\) to the nonzero scalar \(\lambda([v])\), a contradiction. Hence \([v]=0\), which means \(v\in P\).

Step 5. Prove primality

Choose a basis of \(V/P\). Its symmetric algebra is a polynomial algebra over the field \(k\), and therefore a domain. The isomorphism from Steps 1–3 makes \(A/I_P\) a domain. This is exactly the primality of \(I_P\).

Step 6. Reduce the generating set

If \(P\) is spanned by a set \(S\), then \[ I_P=(\iota(s):s\in S). \] One containment follows from \(S\subseteq P\). For the other, every \(v\in P\) is a finite linear combination of elements of \(S\); linearity of \(\iota\) expresses \(\iota(v)\) in the ideal on the right. This is the source's ideal_span_eq statement.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.ideal_le_ker: PlaneLocalization.lean:27.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.forward: PlaneLocalization.lean:33.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.linearQuotient: PlaneLocalization.lean:37.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.backward: PlaneLocalization.lean:44.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.quotientEquiv: PlaneLocalization.lean:56.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.quotientEquiv_mk_ι: PlaneLocalization.lean:76.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.ι_mem_iff: PlaneLocalization.lean:80.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.ideal_eq_ker: PlaneLocalization.lean:98.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.ideal_isPrime: PlaneLocalization.lean:107.

OAI.KLInvariance.SymmetricPlaneIdeal.ideal_span_eq: PlaneLocalization.lean:111.

Used by