Scalar quotients and saturated submodules
Let \(A\) be a commutative ring, \(M\) an \(A\)-module, and \(a\in A\). The scalar multiple submodule is \[ aM=\{am:m\in M\}. \] The scalar quotient \(M/aM\) consists of classes with \(m\sim m'\) exactly when \(m-m'\in aM\).
Multiplication by \(a\) acts as zero on this quotient. Therefore its scalar action factors through \(A/(a)\): \[ [r]\,[m]=[rm]. \] Changing \(r\) by a multiple of \(a\), or \(m\) by an element of \(aM\), leaves the class unchanged.
A scalar \(a\) is regular on \(M\) when multiplication \(m\mapsto am\) is injective. Equivalently, \(am=0\) implies \(m=0\). This property specifies the module on which cancellation is valid.
Reduction of an inclusion
For \(S\subseteq M\), inclusion induces \[ S/aS\longrightarrow M/aM,\qquad [s]\longmapsto[s]. \] Its kernel consists of classes represented by \(S\cap aM\). Thus it is injective exactly when \[ S\cap aM=aS. \]
Call \(S\) saturated with respect to \(a\) when \(am\in S\) implies \(m\in S\). Then an element \(s=am\in S\cap aM\) has \(m\in S\), so \(s\in aS\). The reverse inclusion is immediate. Saturation therefore makes the reduced inclusion injective.
A submodule in a module already acted on by the quotient
Let \(N\) have compatible actions of \(A\) and \(C=A/(a)\), meaning \[ r v=\overline r\,v\qquad(r\in A,\ v\in N). \] For an \(A\)-submodule \(S\subseteq N\), the same subset is a \(C\)-submodule. Indeed, for \(c\in C\), choose a representative \(r\in A\). If \(v\in S\), then \(cv=rv\in S\). Closure under addition and zero is unchanged.
Lean calls this object ScalarQuotient.submodule a S. It retains the original vectors and membership condition while expressing their scalar stability over \(C\). The scalar-image theorem uses this coefficient action for the actual upper edge image and its correction multiple.
A homogeneous scalar
If \(M\) is graded and \(a\) is homogeneous, \(aM\) is a homogeneous submodule, so \(M/aM\) has an induced grading. The quotient map has degree zero. The multiplication map \(m\mapsto am\) changes degree by \(\deg a\).
For \(A=k[X,Y]\), the quotient \(A/XA\) is \(k[Y]\). The element \(Y\) remains nonzero, while every multiple of \(X\) vanishes.
In an edge calculation, \(a\) is the root label and \(A/(a)\) is the edge coefficient ring. Saturation identifies the reduced upper kernel with its actual image in the edge module.
Relation to the OpenAI notes
Compatible quotient actions and the actual free upper image.
OpenAI notes: The notes identify the upper image with the selected upper kernel modulo the current root label. Saturation gives this quotient, and freeness of the upper kernel gives freeness over the edge coefficient ring. Multiplication by the nonzero correction then gives the free target. edge:bound.
Lean (primary): The quotient action and its scalar tower are explicit. A finite free scalar presentation gives the edge-module basis. Regularity of the incoming label on every outgoing edge module gives saturation; Noetherian finiteness permits the finite quotient presentation. A separate same-carrier quotient-submodule construction and injective scalar-image map give freeness of the corrected target. TerminalKernels:613, TerminalKernels:624, TerminalKernels:681, TerminalKernels:691, TerminalKernels:880.
Role in the proof: The Blueprint retains the precise coefficient ring of each freeness statement, all action compatibilities, the arbitrary outgoing selection and the finite-basis hypothesis used for finiteness.
References
The local source declarations below define the constructions and prove the stated properties.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.scalarQuotient: GradedModules.lean:1122.
OAI.KLInvariance.EdgeImage.reducedInclusion: ModuleAlgebra.lean:413.
OAI.KLInvariance.ScalarQuotient.submodule: TerminalKernels.lean:613.
Used by
- Hilbert values of a regular homogeneous scalar image and quotient
- Saturated kernels and their free reduced images
- The Hilbert value of an actual saturated image
- Free presentations over a scalar quotient and their kernels
- Scalar images over a quotient ring preserve freeness under injectivity
- A basis descends through a scalar-kernel presentation
- Regular scalars on a quotient of a finite free module
- Tensor extension of a principal scalar quotient
- Attaching a new bottom stalk by a minimal cover
- Freeness of a saturated image over the edge quotient ring
- Recovering a projective kernel from scaled image equality
- The upper-end edge quotient rule
- Plane denominators force membership in a free edge-ring target
- The upper edge image is free over its quotient coefficient ring
- Saturation of a twisted pair lattice from quotient regularity