Theorem Prime character classes are single weights or reflection pairs
✓ theorem proved

Prime character classes are single weights or reflection pairs

Fix a finite-generator Coxeter system, its symmetric coefficient algebra \(A\), and a prime element \(p\in A\). Suppose \(x\ne y\) and \[ p\mid\chi_x(f)-\chi_y(f)\qquad(f\in A). \] Then \(t=yx^{-1}\) is a reflection, \(y=tx\), and the entire residue class of \(x\) in \(W\) is \[ C_x=\{x,tx\}. \] Moreover, \(p\) is associated to the linear polynomial of a root representing \(t\). Thus each prime character class is either a singleton or a reflection pair.

Proof

Step 1. Find a nonzero displacement

Set \(w=yx^{-1}\). Since \(x\ne y\), \(w\ne1\). If every displacement were zero, the action of \(w\) would be the identity, and faithfulness would force \(w=1\). Hence there is \(v\in V\) with \[ d=wv-v\ne0. \]

For any \(z\in V\), substitute \(f=\chi_x^{-1}(\iota(z))\) into the character congruence. The character difference is \(\iota(z-wz)\). Divisibility also holds for its negative, giving \[ p\mid\iota(wz-z). \] In particular, \(p\mid\iota(d)\).

Step 2. Replace the prime by a nonzero linear generator

Because \(d\ne0\), the polynomial \(\iota(d)\) is prime by the linear-prime theorem. The two prime elements \(p,\iota(d)\) are associated, since \(p\mid\iota(d)\).

Therefore, for every \(z\), \[ \iota(d)\mid\iota(wz-z). \] The linear-divisibility criterion gives \(wz-z\in\mathbb Rd\). Hence \[ \operatorname{im}(w-1)\subseteq\mathbb Rd. \] The reverse inclusion holds because \(d=(w-1)v\) belongs to the image, which is a linear subspace. Thus the moving space equals the line \(\mathbb Rd\) and has dimension one.

Step 3. Identify a reflection

Reflection faithfulness of the extended realization says that a group element with one-dimensional moving space is a reflection. Apply it to \(w\), and set \(t=w\). Then \(t\) is a reflection and \(y=tx\).

Step 4. Replace the prime by this reflection's root polynomial

Choose a positive root \(a\) representing \(t\), and put \(\alpha=\iota(\operatorname{embed}(a))\). The reflection-character difference construction gives a coefficient \[ c=\chi_x^{-1}(\alpha/2) \] with \(\chi_x(c)-\chi_{tx}(c)=\alpha\).

The assumed congruence of \(x\) and \(y=tx\) therefore gives \(p\mid\alpha\). The nonzero root polynomial \(\alpha\) is prime, so \(p\) and \(\alpha\) are associated.

Step 5. Classify every member of the class

Associated elements define the same divisibility conditions. For every \(z\in W\), \[ \begin{aligned} x\sim_p z &\Longleftrightarrow \alpha\mid\chi_x(f)-\chi_z(f)\text{ for every }f\\ &\Longleftrightarrow z=x\text{ or }z=tx, \end{aligned} \] by the root-character congruence theorem.

If a class has no element distinct from its chosen member, it is a singleton. Otherwise Steps 1–5 identify it with the stated pair. On a subset of weights, its class is the intersection of that pair with the subset.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.isReflection_of_prime_character_congruence: IntegralPairings.lean:1572.

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.prime_character_class: IntegralPairings.lean:1620.

Used by