The image of a product of pre-reflections
Let \(V\) be a vector space over a field \(k\), let \(\alpha,\beta\in V\), and let \(f,g\in V^*\) be linearly independent. Put \[ r_{\alpha,f}(v)=v-f(v)\alpha. \] Then \[ \operatorname{im}(r_{\alpha,f}r_{\beta,g}-1) =\operatorname{span}_k\{\alpha,\beta\}. \]
Proof
Step 1. Expand the composite in the stated order
Write \(r_{\alpha,f}(v)=v-f(v)\alpha\) and \(r_{\beta,g}(v)=v-g(v)\beta\). First apply the second map: \[ r_{\alpha,f}(r_{\beta,g}(v)) =v-g(v)\beta-f(v-g(v)\beta)\alpha. \] Linearity of \(f\) gives \[ (r_{\alpha,f}r_{\beta,g}-1)(v) =(-f(v)+f(\beta)g(v))\alpha-g(v)\beta. \] Thus every image vector lies in \(\operatorname{span}\{\alpha,\beta\}\).
Step 2. Surjectivity of the pair of functionals
The independent-form surjectivity theorem applies to \(f,g\). It gives surjectivity of \[ F:V\to k^2,\qquad F(v)=(f(v),g(v)). \] Its proof expands a functional vanishing on the image into its two coordinate coefficients. Independence forces both coefficients to vanish, so the image is the whole coordinate plane.
Step 3. Produce a preimage for an arbitrary vector in the plane
Take \(a\alpha+b\beta\). By Step 2 choose \(v\) satisfying \[ g(v)=-b,\qquad f(v)=-a-bf(\beta). \] Substitution into the expression in Step 1 gives coefficient \(-f(v)+f(\beta)g(v)=a\) at \(\alpha\), and coefficient \(-g(v)=b\) at \(\beta\). Therefore the chosen plane vector lies in the image.
The two containments prove equality.
References
2. Real realizations and moment-graph sheaves.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionPlane.range_preReflection_product_sub_id: ReflectionPlane.lean:44.
OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionPlane.formPair_surjective: ReflectionPlane.lean:16.