Theorem Prescribed values of two independent linear forms
✓ theorem proved

Prescribed values of two independent linear forms

Let \(k\) be a field, \(V\) a \(k\)-vector space, and \(f,g:V\to k\) linearly independent linear forms. Then \[ F:V\to k^2,\qquad F(v)=(f(v),g(v)) \] is surjective. Thus any two prescribed scalars are simultaneously attained by \(f,g\).

Proof

Step 1. Expand a functional on the coordinate plane

Let \(L:k^2\to k\) be linear and suppose it vanishes on the image of \(F\). Since \[ (a,b)=a(1,0)+b(0,1), \] one has \[ L(a,b)=aL(1,0)+bL(0,1). \] Substituting \(F(v)\) gives \[ L(1,0)f(v)+L(0,1)g(v)=0 \] for every \(v\).

Step 2. Use independence to determine that functional

The last equality is the relation \[ L(1,0)f+L(0,1)g=0. \] Independence forces both coefficients to vanish. Step 1 then gives \(L(a,b)=0\) for every pair, so \(L=0\).

Thus the only linear functional on \(k^2\) vanishing on \(\operatorname{im}F\) is zero.

Step 3. Conclude surjectivity

A proper subspace of \(k^2\) admits a nonzero functional vanishing on it. For the zero subspace, use a coordinate functional. For a line spanned by a nonzero \((a,b)\), use \[ (x,y)\longmapsto bx-ay. \] This functional is nonzero because \((a,b)\ne(0,0)\), and it vanishes on the line. These are the possible proper-subspace dimensions.

Step 2 therefore forces \(\operatorname{im}F=k^2\), proving surjectivity. The source expresses this argument as injectivity of the dual map followed by the dual-map criterion for surjectivity.

In the reflection application, \(f,g\) are the two normal forms and the prescribed pair is \((-1,0)\).

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionPlane.formPair_surjective: ReflectionPlane.lean:16.

Used by