Theorem Hilbert values of a regular homogeneous scalar image and quotient
✓ theorem proved

Hilbert values of a regular homogeneous scalar image and quotient

Let \(k\) be a field and \(A\) a commutative \(k\)-algebra. Use the source Hilbert values for a compatibly graded \(A\)-module \(M\), and let \(a\in A_d\) be homogeneous of integer degree \(d\). Assume multiplication by \(a\) on \(M\) is injective.

If \(q\ne0\) and the series for \(M\) converges, then \[ H_{aM}(q)=q^dH_M(q). \] If also the pieces of \(M\) are finite-dimensional and \(q>0\), then \[ H_{M/aM}(q)=(1-q^d)H_M(q). \]

Relation to the OpenAI notes

Explicit convergence and degreewise comparison.

OpenAI notes: The graded-rank paragraph gives \(\operatorname{Hilb}(M;q)=\operatorname{grk}_A(M;q)/(1-q)^N\) for a homogeneous free basis. The comparison evaluates Hilbert series at \(0<q<1\), uses the factor \(1-q\) for a degree-one scalar quotient, and detects equality through a positive quotient deficit. sec:background, eq:state, eq:image-equality.

Lean (primary): The implementation defines real integer-indexed terms from the finite ranks of intersections with ambient pieces. Finite homogeneous covers prove piece finiteness and summability. Degreewise exactness proves the scalar-quotient factor, and inclusion plus homogeneity of the larger subspace turns one equal positive Hilbert value into equality. ModuleAlgebra:506, HilbertSeries:245, Support:1186, ModuleAlgebra:549.

Role in the proof: The KB distinguishes the formal coefficient series, its convergent real value and the free-module basis-degree polynomial. The factor \((1-q)^N\) removes the coefficient-ring contribution; \(1-q\) records quotienting by a regular degree-one label.

Proof

Step 1. Identify the pieces of the scalar image

Multiplication gives \[ M_{n-d}\longrightarrow(aM)_n,\qquad m\longmapsto am. \] It is injective by the assumption on multiplication.

For surjectivity, take \(av\in M_n\). Component transport gives \[ a\,\pi_{n-d}(v)=\pi_n(av)=av. \] Thus every homogeneous image vector comes from \(M_{n-d}\). This is a \(k\)-linear equivalence, so \(\dim_k(aM)_n=\dim_kM_{n-d}\).

Step 2. Shift the convergent series

Translate the integer index by \(d\): \[ \begin{aligned} H_{aM}(q) &=\sum_n\dim_kM_{n-d}\,q^n\\ &=q^d\sum_m\dim_kM_m\,q^m =q^dH_M(q). \end{aligned} \] The identity \(q^{m+d}=q^mq^d\) uses \(q\ne0\). Translation and multiplication by the fixed scalar preserve convergence.

Step 3. Apply homogeneous exactness to the quotient map

The image \(aM\) is homogeneous by the scalar component formula. The quotient map has degree zero, is surjective and has kernel \(aM\).

For finite-dimensional pieces and positive \(q\), Hilbert exactness gives \[ H_M(q)=H_{aM}(q)+H_{M/aM}(q). \] Substitute Step 2 and rearrange to obtain the quotient formula.

Step 4. Specialize to a degree-one label

For \(d=1\), \[ H_{M/aM}(q)=(1-q)H_M(q). \] For a nonzero linear label \(a\) and a graded free module over \(A=k[X_1,\ldots,X_N]\), multiplication is injective because the coefficient ring is a domain. Hence \[ H_{M/aM}(q) =(1-q)\frac{\operatorname{grk}_A(M;q)}{(1-q)^N} =\frac{\operatorname{grk}_A(M;q)}{(1-q)^{N-1}}. \]

For \(A=k[X]\), \(a=X\), and \(M=A\oplus A(2)\), the quotient has basis classes in degrees zero and two over \(k\). Its Hilbert value is \(1+q^2\), equal to \[ (1-q)\frac{1+q^2}{1-q}. \] This is the factor used when the sheaf comparison passes from an upper kernel to its edge quotient.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.scalarDegreeMap: Support.lean:1124.

OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.scalarDegreeMap_surjective: Support.lean:1132.

OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.scalarDegreeMap_injective: Support.lean:1146.

OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.scalarDegreeEquiv: Support.lean:1153.

OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.scalar_value: Support.lean:1161.

OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.scalarQuotient_value: Support.lean:1186.

Used by