The reflection trace lowers degree by one
Let \(k\) be a characteristic-zero field, \(A\) a commutative domain over \(k\), and \((\tau,\alpha)\) reflection data with fixed algebra \(R=A^\tau\). Suppose \[ A=\bigoplus_{n\in\mathbb Z} A_n,\qquad A_iA_j\subseteq A_{i+j}, \] where the pieces are \(k\)-subspaces. Assume \(\alpha\in A_1\) and \(\tau(A_n)\subseteq A_n\) for every \(n\).
For homogeneous \(a\in A_n\), its reflection coordinates satisfy \[ a=a_0+\alpha a_1,\qquad a_0\in R\cap A_n,\qquad a_1=t(a)\in R\cap A_{n-1}. \] When \(1\in A_0\), the reflection basis \(1,\alpha\) has degrees \(0,1\).
Proof
Step 1. Express the trace by a homogeneous product
Applying \(\tau\) to the coordinate expansion gives \(\tau(a)=a_0-\alpha a_1\). Subtracting yields \[ 2\alpha t(a)=a-\tau(a). \] The automorphism preserves \(A_n\). Since \(A_n\) is a \(k\)-subspace, both the difference and its half belong to \(A_n\). Thus \[ \alpha t(a)=\frac12(a-\tau(a))\in A_n. \]
Step 2. Recover the degree of the trace
The homogeneous-scalar cancellation theorem applies to the nonzero homogeneous scalar \(\alpha\in A_1\). It gives \(t(a)\in A_{n-1}\).
Concretely, write \(t(a)=\sum_j c_j\), with \(c_j\in A_j\) and finite support. Then \(\alpha c_j\in A_{j+1}\). Uniqueness of homogeneous components in the equality \(\alpha t(a)\in A_n\) gives \(\alpha c_j=0\) for \(j+1\ne n\). Cancellation of \(\alpha\) gives \(c_j=0\) for these indices, leaving only \(c_{n-1}\). This also covers the zero trace value.
Step 3. Recover the degree of the first coordinate
From the expansion, \[ a_0=a-\alpha t(a). \] Both terms on the right lie in \(A_n\), so \(a_0\in A_n\). The coordinate construction already places \(a_0,t(a)\) in \(R\).
Step 4. Read off the basis degrees
The source identifies reflectionBasis at indices \(0,1\) with \(1,\alpha\). The additional hypothesis \(1\in A_0\) and the given \(\alpha\in A_1\) supply their degrees.
For \(A=k[X]\) with \(\deg X=1\), the trace sends \(X^{2m}\) to zero and \(X^{2m+1}\) to \(X^{2m}\). Each nonzero image lowers degree by one, illustrating the general formula.
References
The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.trace_difference: Frobenius.lean:456.
OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.trace_homogeneous: Frobenius.lean:464.
OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.coordinates_homogeneous: Frobenius.lean:483.
OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.reflectionBasis_homogeneous: Frobenius.lean:533.