The basis and pairing degree of one reflection tensor step
Let \(A\) be a commutative domain over a characteristic-zero field \(k\), equipped with an integer grading by \(k\)-subspaces, with \(1\in A_0\) and \(A_iA_j\subseteq A_{i+j}\). Let \((\tau,\alpha)\) be reflection data such that \(\alpha\in A_1\) and \(\tau\) preserves the grading. Put \(R=A^\tau\), and let \(t\) be the reflection trace.
Let \(N\) be a finite free paired \(A\)-module with basis \((b_j)_{j\in J}\). Assign integers \(d_j\) to its basis vectors. Suppose that for some integer \(L\), \[ B_N(b_j,b_k)\in A_{d_j+d_k-L} \qquad(j,k\in J). \] Then the induced module \(N'=A\otimes_R N\) has basis \[ e_{\varepsilon,j}=1\otimes r_\varepsilon b_j, \qquad r_0=1,\quad r_1=\alpha,\quad \varepsilon\in\{0,1\}, \] and its pairing satisfies \[ B'(e_{\varepsilon,j},e_{\delta,k}) \in A_{(\varepsilon+d_j)+(\delta+d_k)-(L+1)}. \] Here \(d_j\) is a basis-degree assignment; the displayed hypothesis is the precise condition on the old pairing entries.
Relation to the OpenAI notes
Explicit tensor construction underlying the duality.
OpenAI notes: The grading-normalization proof starts from a normalized self-dual projective, uses the cited moment-graph/Soergel equivalence and character theorem, and translates doubled degrees back to the degree-one convention. bg:normalization.
Lean (primary): The local construction begins with the simple reflection fixed algebra and the trace extracting the root coefficient, normalized by t(alpha)=1. It recovers linear functionals through the trace, extends the resulting duality by tensor product, and proves a one-degree pairing shift for each letter. Decomposition:1588, Frobenius:168, Frobenius:270, Frobenius:602.
Role in the proof: These nodes supply the actual word-module pairing and its homogeneous basis calculation. The boundary-pairing construction subsequently transports this pairing to a boundary summand. The source uses roots of degree one throughout this tensor calculation.
Proof
Step 1. Construct the new basis
The reflection coordinate theorem makes \((r_0,r_1)\) an \(R\)-basis of \(A\). The product-basis construction makes \((r_\varepsilon b_j)\) an \(R\)-basis of \(N\). Extending scalars gives the claimed \(A\)-basis \(e_{\varepsilon,j}\) of \(N'\).
The source constructs inducedBasis by exactly these two operations: the scalar-tower basis followed by base change. Its inducedBasis_apply formula identifies each vector with the displayed pure tensor.
Step 2. Evaluate its pairing
The tensor-pairing formula at outer coefficients \(1,1\) gives \[ B'(e_{\varepsilon,j},e_{\delta,k}) =t\bigl(B_N(r_\varepsilon b_j,r_\delta b_k)\bigr), \] viewing the trace value in \(A\) through the inclusion \(R\to A\). Bilinearity of the old pairing yields \[ B'(e_{\varepsilon,j},e_{\delta,k}) =t\bigl(r_\varepsilon r_\delta B_N(b_j,b_k)\bigr). \]
Step 3. Compute the degree inside the trace
The reflection basis elements satisfy \(r_\varepsilon\in A_\varepsilon\) and \(r_\delta\in A_\delta\). Multiplying these two homogeneous elements with the assumed pairing entry gives \[ r_\varepsilon r_\delta B_N(b_j,b_k) \in A_{\varepsilon+\delta+d_j+d_k-L}. \]
Step 4. Apply the one-degree trace shift
The reflection trace lowers the degree by one, so the expression from Step 2 lies in \[ A_{\varepsilon+\delta+d_j+d_k-L-1}. \] Rearranging the index gives \[ \varepsilon+\delta+d_j+d_k-L-1 =(\varepsilon+d_j)+(\delta+d_k)-(L+1), \] as required. Thus assigning degree \(\varepsilon+d_j\) to the new basis increases the pairing shift from \(L\) to \(L+1\).
Starting from \(N=A\), basis \(1\), assigned degree \(0\), and \(L=0\), one step gives basis degrees \(0,1\) and pairing shift \(1\). Iterating this result is the basis-level induction in the word-pairing degree theorem.
References
The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.FrobeniusDuality.inducedBasis: Frobenius.lean:569.
OAI.KLInvariance.FrobeniusDuality.inducedBasis_apply: Frobenius.lean:574.
OAI.KLInvariance.FrobeniusDuality.inducedPairing_basis: Frobenius.lean:580.
OAI.KLInvariance.FrobeniusDuality.inducedPairing_basis_homogeneous: Frobenius.lean:602.