Theorem A linear reflection induces Frobenius data on its symmetric algebra
✓ theorem proved

A linear reflection induces Frobenius data on its symmetric algebra

Let \(V\) be a vector space over a characteristic-zero field \(k\). Choose a vector \(r\in V\) and a linear functional \(\varphi:V\to k\) with \(\varphi(r)=2\). Put \[ s(v)=v-\varphi(v)r,\qquad A=\operatorname{Sym}_k(V),\qquad \alpha=\iota(r), \] where \(\iota:V\to A\) is the symmetric-algebra generator map.

The linear reflection induces a \(k\)-algebra automorphism \(\tau\) determined by \[ \tau(\iota(v))=\iota(s(v)). \] It satisfies \[ \tau^2=1,\qquad \alpha\ne0,\qquad \tau(\alpha)=-\alpha,\qquad \alpha\mid a-\tau(a)\quad(a\in A). \] Thus \(A^\tau\to A\) has the reflection coordinates and perfect trace pairing.

Proof

Step 1. Construct the involution on generators

The root-coroot normalization gives \[ \varphi(s(v))=\varphi(v)-\varphi(v)\varphi(r)=-\varphi(v). \] Therefore \[ s(s(v))=v-\varphi(v)r+\varphi(v)r=v. \] The symmetric-algebra universal property extends the linear map \(\iota\circ s\) to an algebra homomorphism \(\tau:A\to A\).

On each generator, \(\tau^2(\iota(v))=\iota(s^2(v))=\iota(v)\), and \(\tau\) fixes scalar constants. Since these generate \(A\), \(\tau^2=1\). It follows that \(\tau\) is an automorphism with inverse itself.

Step 2. Check the root polynomial

The identity \(\varphi(r)=2\) gives \(s(r)=r-2r=-r\), so \[ \tau(\alpha)=\iota(-r)=-\alpha. \] To prove \(\alpha\ne0\), extend \(\varphi\) to an algebra map \(F:A\to k\). Then \(F(\alpha)=\varphi(r)=2\). If \(\alpha=0\), this would give \(2=0\) in \(k\), contradicting characteristic zero.

Step 3. Prove divisibility on constants and generators

For a constant \(c\in k\), the difference is zero because \(\tau(c)=c\). For a vector generator, \[ \iota(v)-\tau(\iota(v)) =\iota(v)-\iota(v-\varphi(v)r) =\varphi(v)\alpha. \] Both differences are multiples of \(\alpha\).

Step 4. Extend divisibility through polynomial operations

If \(a-\tau(a)=\alpha c\) and \(b-\tau(b)=\alpha d\), then \[ (a+b)-\tau(a+b)=\alpha(c+d). \] For a product, insert and subtract \(\tau(a)b\): \[ \begin{aligned} ab-\tau(ab) &=(a-\tau(a))b+\tau(a)(b-\tau(b))\\ &=\alpha\bigl(cb+\tau(a)d\bigr). \end{aligned} \] Every symmetric-algebra element is built from constants and vector generators by addition and multiplication. Structural induction using Steps 3–4 proves divisibility for every \(a\in A\). These are the four cases of the source's reflectionAction_divisible proof.

Step 5. Apply the reflection trace construction

A basis of \(V\) identifies \(\operatorname{Sym}_k(V)\) with a polynomial algebra, so \(A\) is a commutative domain. Steps 1–4 supply the remaining hypotheses of the reflection Frobenius theorem.

Its basis \(1,\alpha\), coordinate trace and trace duality now apply to the actual induced reflection. This is the source's reflectionDuality construction. The argument permits an arbitrary-dimensional \(V\).

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.symmetricMap: Decomposition.lean:1604.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.symmetricAction: Decomposition.lean:1627.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.symmetricAction_ι: Decomposition.lean:1633.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.reflectionAction: Decomposition.lean:1639.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.reflectionAction_involutive: Decomposition.lean:1643.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.reflectionAction_anti: Decomposition.lean:1654.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.reflectionRoot_ne_zero: Decomposition.lean:1660.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.reflectionAction_divisible: Decomposition.lean:1667.

OAI.KLInvariance.ReflectionFrobenius.reflectionDuality: Decomposition.lean:1687.

Used by