Rotation of a ratio order through a simple reflection
Fix a finite-generator Coxeter system \(W\), original real root space \(V_0\), and ratio order \(O=(h,f)\). Choose a simple generator \(s=s_i\), with simple root \(\alpha_i\), and write \(S=\rho(s)\) for its linear action.
For \(k\in\mathbb R\), define the turned numerator and denominator by
\[
f'=f\circ S,\qquad h'_k=(f-kh)\circ S.
\]
These are turnNumerator and turnDenominator. If
\[
k\ne0,\qquad h'_k(\alpha_j)>0\quad\text{for every simple root }\alpha_j,
\tag{1}
\]
they define the rotated ratio order
\[
O'=\operatorname{turn}(O,i,k)=(h'_k,f').
\]
Its slope is
\[
\sigma_{O'}(a)=\frac{f(Sa)}{f(Sa)-k h(Sa)}.
\tag{2}
\]
The positive representative under a simple reflection
Write \(s\star a\) for the positive-root action: it is the positive representative of the root line of \(Sa\). The simple-root sign theorem says that the only positive root made negative by \(s_i\) is \(\alpha_i\). Consequently \[ s\star\alpha_i=\alpha_i,\qquad s\star a=Sa\quad(a\ne\alpha_i). \] The map \(s\star-\) is an involution on positive roots. Since it fixes \(\alpha_i\), it carries every other positive root to another root different from \(\alpha_i\).
Genericity of the new ratio
The positivity condition in (1) makes \(h'_k\) positive on every positive root. Thus every denominator in (2) is nonzero. For positive roots \(a,b\), put \[ A_a=f(Sa),\quad B_a=h(Sa),\qquad A_b=f(Sb),\quad B_b=h(Sb). \] The numbers \(B_a,B_b\) are also nonzero: \(Sa\) and \(Sb\) are positive or negative roots, and \(h\) has a strict sign on each of those two alternatives.
If the new slopes agree, cross multiplication gives \[ A_a(A_b-kB_b)=A_b(A_a-kB_a). \] Cancel \(A_aA_b\) and use \(k\ne0\). The result is \[ A_aB_b=A_bB_a,\qquad \frac{A_a}{B_a}=\frac{A_b}{B_b}. \] Replacing a root by its negative changes both numerator and denominator signs, so these two ratios are \(\sigma_O(s\star a)\) and \(\sigma_O(s\star b)\). The original slope is injective, and \(s\star-\) is a bijection. Hence \(s\star a=s\star b\), then \(a=b\).
This proves the genericity field turn_ratio_injective. Together with (1), it supplies all fields of the new ratio order.
The fractional-linear slope formula
For \(a\ne\alpha_i\), one has \(S(s\star a)=a\). Put \(u=\sigma_O(a)\). Evaluating (2) at \(s\star a\) gives \[ \sigma_{O'}(s\star a) =\frac{f(a)}{f(a)-k h(a)} =\frac{u}{u-k}. \tag{3} \] The denominator \(u-k\) is positive, because \(h'_k(s\star a)=h(a)(u-k)>0\). For the simple root, with \(c=\sigma_O(\alpha_i)\), the formula is \[ \sigma_{O'}(\alpha_i)=\frac{c}{c-k}. \tag{4} \] The order-rotation theorem chooses a negative \(k\) satisfying (1), makes (4) the greatest slope, and uses (3) to preserve the comparisons among all other reflected roots.
The existing A2 order after rotation
Take simple roots \(a,b\), height denominator \(h\), and numerator \(f(a)=-1\), \(f(b)=3\). The original slopes of \(a,a+b,b\) are \(-1,1,3\). Reflect in \(a\), so \[ Sa=-a,\qquad Sb=a+b,\qquad S(a+b)=b, \] and choose \(k=-1/2\). Direct substitution gives \[ \begin{aligned} f'(a)&=1,& h'_k(a)&=1/2,\\ f'(b)&=2,& h'_k(b)&=3,\\ f'(a+b)&=3,& h'_k(a+b)&=7/2. \end{aligned} \] Thus \[ \sigma_{O'}(b)=2/3,\qquad \sigma_{O'}(a+b)=6/7,\qquad \sigma_{O'}(a)=2. \] The simple root \(a\) moves from least to greatest. The old slope comparison \(\sigma_O(a+b)=1<3=\sigma_O(b)\) becomes \(\sigma_{O'}(b)=2/3<6/7=\sigma_{O'}(a+b)\) after applying the positive-root reflection to both roots. This is an illustrative calculation of the source construction.
Relation to the OpenAI notes
A fractional-linear change of slopes at a simple descent.
OpenAI notes: The background path formula is cited for reflection orders, with the decreasing version obtained by reversing an order. bg:paths.
Lean (primary): The adapted proof explicitly constructs a second ratio order: compose the numerator with a simple reflection and compose numerator minus k times denominator with the same reflection. A finite positive-gap choice gives negative k and a positive new denominator. The new chamber is indexed by the shorter element; the chosen simple root becomes greatest and other reflected comparisons are preserved. DyerPaths:1369, DyerPaths:1372, DyerPaths:1413, DyerPaths:1375, DyerPaths:1459, DyerPaths:1468, DyerPaths:1489, DyerPaths:1527.
Role in the proof: The construction retains its generic k!=0 and positivity hypotheses, while the rotation theorem states its negative-parameter conditions. The A2 example computes the old and new slopes through the same formulas.
References
The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.positiveAction_simplePositive: DyerPaths.lean:1327.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.simple_action_nonneg: DyerPaths.lean:1334.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.simple_positiveAction_val: DyerPaths.lean:1340.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.simple_positiveAction_ne: DyerPaths.lean:1345.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.RatioOrder.turnNumerator: DyerPaths.lean:1369.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.RatioOrder.turnDenominator: DyerPaths.lean:1372.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.RatioOrder.turn_ratio_injective: DyerPaths.lean:1413.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.RatioOrder.turn: DyerPaths.lean:1454.