Reflections, length, and reflection edges of the induced plane system
Let \(D_P\) have the Coxeter system constructed from a plane basis of a root plane \(P\). Then:
- An element of \(D_P\) is an intrinsic reflection exactly when it is an ambient reflection in \(W\).
- For \(w\in D_P\), its intrinsic length is the ambient plane inversion count: \[ \ell_P(w)=L_P(w). \]
- Left inversions agree in the two systems for \(w,t\in D_P\).
- For \(g,h\in D_P\), a directed intrinsic reflection edge \(g\to h\) is exactly an ambient directed reflection edge between those same elements.
Proof
Step 1. Send intrinsic reflections to ambient reflections
An intrinsic reflection is a conjugate \(u s_i u^{-1}\) of an induced simple reflection. The two simple reflections are the ambient reflections of the plane endpoints.
The inclusion \(D_P\hookrightarrow W\) preserves products and inverses, and ambient reflections are closed under conjugation. Thus every intrinsic reflection is an ambient one.
Step 2. Recover intrinsic reflections from ambient ones
Let \(t\in D_P\) be an ambient reflection, and let \(a\) be its positive representing root. The reflection-membership theorem gives \(a\in P\).
Since \(t^{-1}=t\) and \(t(a)=-a\), the root \(a\) is negative under \(t^{-1}\). Apply the induced inversion-sign theorem with \(w=t\). It makes \(t\) an intrinsic left inversion of itself, which in particular makes it an intrinsic reflection.
Step 3. Construct the inversion bijection and count it
For fixed \(w\in D_P\), send a positive plane root inverted by \(w\) to its reflection: \[ a\longmapsto r_a\in D_P. \] The sign theorem makes this an intrinsic left inversion of \(w\).
Conversely, an intrinsic left inversion \(t\) is an ambient reflection by Step 1. Its unique positive root lies in \(P\), and the sign theorem makes that root an ambient inversion of \(w\). Uniqueness of positive representing roots shows that these two maps are inverse.
The left inversions of a Coxeter element are in bijection with the positions of a reduced word: the inversion sequence lists them without repetition. There are \(\ell_P(w)\) such positions. The other side of our bijection has cardinality \(L_P(w)\). Therefore \(L_P(w)=\ell_P(w)\).
Step 4. Compare the two left-inversion conditions
If \(t\) is not an ambient reflection, Step 1 shows it is not an intrinsic reflection, so both left-inversion conditions are false.
Otherwise let \(a\in\Phi^+\cap P\) represent \(t\). The intrinsic sign theorem and the ambient root-sign theorem both characterize their respective left-inversion condition by negativity of the same root \(w^{-1}a\). Thus the conditions agree.
Step 5. Compare directed reflection edges
Suppose \(g\to h\) is an ambient edge, so \(h=tg\) for an ambient reflection \(t\), with \(\ell_W(g)<\ell_W(h)\). Since \(g,h\in D_P\), \(t=hg^{-1}\in D_P\). Also \(th=g\), so \(t\) is an ambient left inversion of \(h\).
Steps 2 and 4 make it an intrinsic reflection and an intrinsic left inversion of \(h\). Therefore \(\ell_P(g)<\ell_P(h)\), giving the intrinsic edge.
Conversely, start with an intrinsic edge \(h=tg\). Step 1 makes \(t\) ambient, and Step 4 transfers its left-inversion condition at \(h\), giving the ambient length inequality. The edge relation and its reflection label are the same in both directions.
References
The local source declarations below define the objects and prove the stated properties.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.PlaneBasis.reflection_iff: Decomposition.lean:1058.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.PlaneBasis.inversionEquiv: Decomposition.lean:1083.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.PlaneBasis.length_eq: Decomposition.lean:1108.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.PlaneBasis.leftInversion_iff: Decomposition.lean:1141.
OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.PlaneBasis.bruhatStep_iff: Decomposition.lean:1153.