Theorem Root labels in a localized edge quotient
✓ theorem proved

Root labels in a localized edge quotient

Fix a finite-generator Coxeter system, its original root space \(V_0\), and the embedding \(i_0:V_0\hookrightarrow V\) into the extended realization. A finite real basis gives polynomial coordinates \(\Phi:\operatorname{Sym}_{\mathbb R}(V)\to A\) and labels \(\lambda(v)=\Phi(\iota(i_0v))\).

For any subspace \(P\subseteq V_0\) and vector \(a\), use the maps \[ \eta_P:A\to R_P=A_{\mathfrak p_P},\qquad q_{P,a}:R_P\to E_{P,a}=R_P/(\eta_P(\lambda(a))), \] \[ \lambda_P=\eta_P\lambda,\qquad r_{P,a}=q_{P,a}\eta_P\lambda. \] The map \(r_{P,a}\) is the localized reduction that kills \(a\).

Let \(a,b,c\) be positive roots with \[ c\in P(a,b)=\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb R}\{a,b\}, \qquad c\ne a. \] Then \(r_{P,a}(c)\) and \(r_{P,a}(b)\) are associated scalars in \(E_{P,a}\). More explicitly, some nonzero real scalar \(r\) satisfies \[ r_{P,a}(c)=r\,r_{P,a}(b). \]

The actual polynomial root labels commute with the coefficient maps: \[ \eta_P(\operatorname{polynomialRoot}(c))=\lambda_P(c), \] \[ q_{P,a}\bigl(\eta_P(\operatorname{polynomialRoot}(c))\bigr) =r_{P,a}(c). \]

Relation to the OpenAI notes

Explicit coefficient maps and scalar reduction.

OpenAI notes: The edge-image proof localizes at the plane prime, passes to the quotient by the current root label, and expresses the remaining plane labels as uniformizers times units in the resulting localized edge ring. edge:bound.

Lean (primary): The coefficient operations are explicit tensor and quotient maps. A real-linear reduction kills the current root; writing another root as sa+rb gives a nonzero field coefficient r and therefore a unit multiple after reduction. The root-label compatibility formulas identify these elements with the actual polynomial labels. MinimalExtensions:1239, PlaneLocalization:1315, PlaneLocalization:1268, PlaneLocalization:1330, PlaneLocalization:1555.

Role in the proof: The reduced-label comparison is an equality up to an explicitly obtained unit. Later product arguments use associated elements in the localized quotient ring to compare actual scalar-image submodules.

Proof

Step 1. Exclude the killed root line

Distinct positive roots are linearly independent. If \(c\) belonged to the line \(\mathbb R a\), there would be a scalar \(s\) with \(c=sa\), contradicting that independence for \(c\ne a\).

Thus \(c\notin\mathbb R a\). This is positiveRoot_not_line.

Step 2. Apply the plane-reduction theorem

The localized reduction map is real-linear and satisfies \(r_{P,a}(a)=0\). The stated plane membership and Step 1 verify the other two hypotheses of the plane-reduction theorem.

Write \(c=sa+rb\). Its proof gives \(r\ne0\) and \[ r_{P,a}(c)=r\,r_{P,a}(b). \] The image of \(r\) is a unit, with inverse the image of \(r^{-1}\). This proves localizedReduction_associated.

The localization subspace \(P\) is arbitrary in this assertion. The span \(P(a,b)\) supplies the linear relation being reduced.

Step 3. Follow the polynomial root through localization

By definition, \[ \operatorname{polynomialRoot}(c) =\Phi(\iota(i_0c))=\lambda(c). \] Applying \(\eta_P\) gives \(\lambda_P(c)\). This is polynomialRoot_localized.

Step 4. Follow the label through the edge quotient

The localized reduction was defined by \(r_{P,a}=q_{P,a}\eta_P\lambda\). Substitute Step 3: \[ q_{P,a}\bigl(\eta_P(\operatorname{polynomialRoot}(c))\bigr) =q_{P,a}(\lambda_P(c)) =r_{P,a}(c). \] This is polynomialRoot_reduced.

The associated labels in Step 2 are therefore the actual reduced polynomial labels used in the edge-module calculation. Their unit relation yields equal principal ideals, and equal scalar-image submodules on any module over \(E_{P,a}\).

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.localizedReduction_self: PlaneLocalization.lean:1320.

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.positiveRoot_not_line: PlaneLocalization.lean:1324.

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.localizedReduction_associated: PlaneLocalization.lean:1330.

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.polynomialRoot_localized: PlaneLocalization.lean:1551.

OAI.KLInvariance.TitsSpace.polynomialRoot_reduced: PlaneLocalization.lean:1555.

Used by