Reduction of a plane along one direction
Let \(k\) be a field, \(V\) a \(k\)-vector space, \(S\) a commutative \(k\)-algebra, and \(l:V\to S\) a \(k\)-linear map. Let \(a,b,c\in V\) satisfy \[ l(a)=0,\qquad c\in\operatorname{span}_k\{a,b\},\qquad c\notin ka. \] Then there is \(r\in k\), \(r\ne0\), with \[ l(c)=r\,l(b). \] Here the scalar action is through the algebra map \(k\to S\). Consequently \(l(c)\) and \(l(b)\) are associated scalars: one is a unit multiple of the other.
Relation to the OpenAI notes
Explicit coefficient maps and scalar reduction.
OpenAI notes: The edge-image proof localizes at the plane prime, passes to the quotient by the current root label, and expresses the remaining plane labels as uniformizers times units in the resulting localized edge ring. edge:bound.
Lean (primary): The coefficient operations are explicit tensor and quotient maps. A real-linear reduction kills the current root; writing another root as sa+rb gives a nonzero field coefficient r and therefore a unit multiple after reduction. The root-label compatibility formulas identify these elements with the actual polynomial labels. MinimalExtensions:1239, PlaneLocalization:1315, PlaneLocalization:1268, PlaneLocalization:1330, PlaneLocalization:1555.
Role in the proof: The reduced-label comparison is an equality up to an explicitly obtained unit. Later product arguments use associated elements in the localized quotient ring to compare actual scalar-image submodules.
Proof
Step 1. Write the two spanning coefficients
Membership in the two-vector span gives scalars \(s,r\in k\) with \[ c=sa+rb. \] If \(r=0\), this becomes \(c=sa\in ka\), contradicting the hypothesis. Hence \(r\ne0\).
Step 2. Apply the linear map
Linearity and \(l(a)=0\) give \[ l(c)=s\,l(a)+r\,l(b)=r\,l(b). \] This is scalar_reduction, with the nonzero coefficient from Step 1.
Step 3. Exhibit the unit in the target algebra
Let \(u\) be the image of \(r\) in \(S\). The image of \(r^{-1}\) is its inverse, since \[ u\,\operatorname{algebraMap}(r^{-1}) =\operatorname{algebraMap}(rr^{-1})=1. \] Thus \(u\) is a unit and \(l(c)=u\,l(b)\), proving associated_reduction.
Step 4. Interpret the equality on scalar images
For any \(S\)-module \(M\), a unit acts bijectively. Therefore \[ l(c)M=u\,l(b)M=l(b)M. \] Explicitly, \(l(c)m=l(b)(um)\), while \(l(b)m=l(c)(u^{-1}m)\). These give both inclusions.
For example, if \(c=3a+2b\) over \(\mathbb R\) and \(l(a)=0\), then \(l(c)=2l(b)\). The unit is the image of the scalar \(2\), with inverse the image of \(1/2\).
References
The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.PlaneReduction.scalar_reduction: PlaneLocalization.lean:1268.
OAI.KLInvariance.PlaneReduction.associated_reduction: PlaneLocalization.lean:1281.