Kernel projectivity from two presentations of one module
Let \(R\) be a commutative ring, and let \[ f:F\twoheadrightarrow I,\qquad g:E\twoheadrightarrow I \] be linear surjections. Assume \(F,E,\ker g\) are projective. Then \(\ker f\) is projective.
Relation to the OpenAI notes
The kernel comparison through explicit splitting maps.
OpenAI notes: After image equality, the notes use a length-one graded free resolution of the edge image and graded Schanuel comparison to obtain a projective kernel. eq:image-equality, sec:induction.
Lean (primary): The module comparison lifts each presentation map through the other and writes an explicit retraction from the sum of one source and the other kernel. The scalar-quotient presentation and actual-image equality supply the required projective kernel. The graded projective-to-free theorem is applied separately. ModuleAlgebra:246, GradedModules:538, PositiveTransfer:970.
Role in the proof: The KB follows the maps used by Lean, with the common image, its two surjections, the regular scalar kernel and the retraction equation all displayed.
Proof
Step 1. Lift the two presentation maps
Projectivity of \(F\) lifts \(f\) through \(g\), giving \(a:F\to E\) with \(ga=f\).
Projectivity of \(E\) lifts \(g\) through \(f\), giving \(b:E\to F\) with \(fb=g\).
Thus, for every \(v\in F\), \(ga(v)=f(v)\), and for every \(e\in E\), \(fb(e)=g(e)\).
Step 2. Map the first kernel into a projective sum
For \(x\in\ker f\), \(g(a(x))=f(x)=0\), so \(a(x)\in\ker g\). Define \[ i:\ker f\longrightarrow F\oplus\ker g,\qquad i(x)=(x,a(x)). \] This is linear, with its second component justified by the displayed kernel equation.
Step 3. Construct the retraction
For \(v\in F\) and \(k\in\ker g\), set \[ r(v,k)=v-ba(v)+b(k). \] It belongs to \(\ker f\), since \[ \begin{aligned} f(r(v,k)) &=f(v)-fb(a(v))+fb(k)\\ &=f(v)-ga(v)+g(k)\\ &=f(v)-f(v)+0=0. \end{aligned} \] The formula is linear in \((v,k)\), so it defines a linear map into the kernel.
Step 4. Verify the splitting equation
For \(x\in\ker f\), \[ ri(x)=r(x,a(x))=x-ba(x)+ba(x)=x. \] Hence \(ri=1_{\ker f}\). This exhibits the new kernel as a direct summand of \(F\oplus\ker g\).
Step 5. Transfer projectivity
Both summands of \(F\oplus\ker g\) are projective, so the finite sum is projective. The split-summand lifting argument then makes \(\ker f\) projective.
The source constructs exactly the maps \(a,b,i,r\) above. The common target \(I\) is the module whose two actual surjections are compared.
References
The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.ReverseFiltration.kernel_projective_of_presentation: ModuleAlgebra.lean:246.