Finite graded polynomial modules have convergent Hilbert values
Let \(k\) be a field and \(A=k[X_1,\ldots,X_N]\), and let \(M\) be any finitely generated \(A\)-module with a compatible integer grading. Then every \(M_n\) is finite-dimensional over \(k\), the grading is bounded below, and \[ \sum_{n\in\mathbb Z}\dim_kM_n\,q^n \] converges for every \(0<q<1\).
For every \(k\)-subspace \(S\subseteq M\), the series of intersection dimensions \(\sum_n\dim_k(S\cap M_n)q^n\) also converges.
Relation to the OpenAI notes
Explicit convergence and degreewise comparison.
OpenAI notes: The graded-rank paragraph gives \(\operatorname{Hilb}(M;q)=\operatorname{grk}_A(M;q)/(1-q)^N\) for a homogeneous free basis. The comparison evaluates Hilbert series at \(0<q<1\), uses the factor \(1-q\) for a degree-one scalar quotient, and detects equality through a positive quotient deficit. sec:background, eq:state, eq:image-equality.
Lean (primary): The implementation defines real integer-indexed terms from the finite ranks of intersections with ambient pieces. Finite homogeneous covers prove piece finiteness and summability. Degreewise exactness proves the scalar-quotient factor, and inclusion plus homogeneity of the larger subspace turns one equal positive Hilbert value into equality. ModuleAlgebra:506, HilbertSeries:245, Support:1186, ModuleAlgebra:549.
Role in the proof: The KB distinguishes the formal coefficient series, its convergent real value and the free-module basis-degree polynomial. The factor \((1-q)^N\) removes the coefficient-ring contribution; \(1-q\) records quotienting by a regular degree-one label.
Proof
Step 1. Construct the finite homogeneous cover
The finite-cover theorem gives a surjective degree-zero map \(f:F\to M\), where \[ F=A^I,\qquad F_n=\prod_iA_{n-d_i} \] for a finite set of integer generator degrees \(d_i\).
Step 2. Restrict the cover to each homogeneous piece
For \(m\in M_n\), choose any preimage \(v\in F\). Component transport gives \(f(\pi_n(v))=\pi_n(m)=m\). Thus \(f_n:F_n\to M_n\) is surjective.
The pieces \(F_n\) are finite-dimensional by the polynomial monomial calculation and finite products. Their quotients \(M_n\) are therefore finite-dimensional, with \[ 0\le\dim_kM_n\le\dim_kF_n. \] When \(n\) lies below all the \(d_i\), \(F_n=0\), hence \(M_n=0\). This proves boundedness below.
Step 3. Compare the nonnegative numerical series
For \(0<q<1\), every \(q^n\) is positive, including for negative \(n\). Multiplying the dimension inequality gives \[ 0\le\dim_kM_n\,q^n\le\dim_kF_n\,q^n. \] The shifted-free Hilbert theorem proves that the upper series converges to \[ \frac{\sum_iq^{d_i}}{(1-q)^N}. \] Comparison of nonnegative series proves convergence for \(M\).
Step 4. Compare an arbitrary ambient subspace
For \(S\subseteq M\), each intersection \(S\cap M_n\) is a subspace of \(M_n\), so \[ 0\le\dim_k(S\cap M_n)q^n\le\dim_kM_nq^n. \] Step 3 supplies a convergent upper series. Comparison therefore proves the final assertion.
For example, with \(A=k[X]\), the quotient \(A/(X)=k\) is generated by the class of one and is covered by \(A\). Its Hilbert value is one. The proof applies through this cover and its degreewise surjections.
References
The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.degreeMap: HilbertSeries.lean:196.
OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.degreeMap_surjective: HilbertSeries.lean:202.
OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.polynomialModule_piece_finite: HilbertSeries.lean:232.
OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.summable_polynomialModule: HilbertSeries.lean:245.
OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.summable_term: HilbertSeries.lean:262.