Theorem Vertex support equals the annihilator of an evaluation kernel
✓ theorem proved

Vertex support equals the annihilator of an evaluation kernel

Let \(R\) be a commutative domain, let each \(A_y\) be a torsion-free \(R\)-module, and let \[ M\subseteq\prod_{y\in V}A_y \] be an \(R\)-submodule. Torsion-free means that \(av=0\) with \(a\ne0\) forces \(v=0\).

Choose \(p\ne0\) such that \(p\delta_y(m_y)\in M\) for every \(y,m\), and write \(C_y m=p\delta_y(m_y)\). Suppose \(D:M\xrightarrow{\sim}M^*\) is a perfect pairing with cut balance: \[ \langle C_y m,n\rangle=\langle m,C_y n\rangle,\qquad \langle m,n\rangle=D(m)(n). \] Let \(\pi_x(m)=m_x\). Then \[ m\in M_{\{x\}} \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \langle m,n\rangle=0\text{ for every }n\in\ker\pi_x. \] Equivalently, \(D(M_{\{x\}})=(\ker\pi_x)^\perp\). The vertex set may be arbitrary.

Proof

Step 1. Supported vectors annihilate the evaluation kernel

Suppose \(m_y=0\) for \(y\ne x\), and let \(n_x=0\). The coordinate identities for cuts give \(C_xm=pm\) and \(C_xn=0\). Consequently \[ p\langle m,n\rangle =\langle pm,n\rangle =\langle C_xm,n\rangle =\langle m,C_xn\rangle=0. \] Cancellation of the nonzero scalar \(p\) in \(R\) gives \(\langle m,n\rangle=0\).

Step 2. A vanishing functional forces every other cut to be zero

Conversely, assume that \(\langle m,n\rangle=0\) whenever \(n_x=0\). Fix a vertex \(y\ne x\), and take any \(n\in M\). The cut \(C_y n\) is supported at \(y\), so its \(x\)-coordinate is zero. Therefore \[ \langle C_y m,n\rangle =\langle m,C_y n\rangle=0. \] This holds for every \(n\), which says \(D(C_y m)\) is the zero functional. Injectivity of \(D\) gives \(C_y m=0\).

Step 3. Recover the zero coordinates

The \(y\)-coordinate of \(C_y m=0\) is \(p\,m_y=0\). Since \(A_y\) is torsion-free and \(p\ne0\), we obtain \(m_y=0\). The argument applies separately to every \(y\ne x\), so \(m\) is supported at \(x\).

Step 1 proves one implication and Steps 2–3 prove its converse. Applying the isomorphism \(D\) gives the stated equality with the dual annihilator.

References

The source declarations below give the definitions and constructions used here.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.IntegralSupport.supported_iff_annihilates: Support.lean:521.

Used by