Theorem Symmetry of the stalk–costalk identification
✓ theorem proved

Symmetry of the stalk–costalk identification

Fix a finite-generator Coxeter system, a Bruhat interval \([u,b]\), and its real polynomial coefficient algebra \(A\). Let \(B\) be a normalized boundary sheaf with a section duality whose pairing \(D\) is symmetric: \[ D(s,t)=D(t,s)\qquad(s,t\in\Gamma(B)). \] At a vertex \(x\), put \[ K_x=\ker\!\left(B^x\xrightarrow{\partial_x} \prod_{e:x\to y}B^e\right), \qquad \kappa_x:K_x\xrightarrow{\sim}(B^x)^*, \] where \(\partial_x(v)=(\rho^-_e(v))_e\) and \((B^x)^*=\operatorname{Hom}_A(B^x,A)\).

Then, for \(k,l\in K_x\), \[ \kappa_x(k)(l)=\kappa_x(l)(k). \] Equivalently, for \(\lambda,\mu\in(B^x)^*\), \[ \lambda\bigl(\kappa_x^{-1}(\mu)\bigr) =\mu\bigl(\kappa_x^{-1}(\lambda)\bigr), \] where kernel elements are evaluated as their underlying stalk vectors.

Proof

Step 1. Express the stalk functional through a supported section

Let \[ \beta_x=\prod_{e:y\to x}\alpha_e \] be the incoming label product. The kernel-to-support equivalence sends \(k\in K_x\) to a global section \(f_x(k)\) supported at \(x\), with \[ f_x(k)_x=\beta_xk. \] The stalk–costalk construction gives, for any global section \(n\), \[ \kappa_x(k)(n_x)=D(f_x(k),n). \]

To see this evaluation formula from the construction, let \(\pi_x:\Gamma(B)\to B^x\) be evaluation at \(x\). The support-to-dual equivalence assigns to a supported section \(s\) the functional \(\lambda\) determined by \[ D(s,n)=\lambda(\pi_x n) \] for every \(n\). Surjectivity of \(\pi_x\) gives uniqueness. Substituting \(s=f_x(k)\) gives the displayed equality. This is costalkEquivDual_pairing.

Step 2. Multiply a kernel pairing by the incoming product

Apply Step 1 with \(n=f_x(l)\). Linearity of \(\kappa_x(k)\) and the formula for the supported section give \[ \begin{aligned} \beta_x\,\kappa_x(k)(l) &=\kappa_x(k)(\beta_xl)\\ &=\kappa_x(k)(f_x(l)_x)\\ &=D(f_x(k),f_x(l)). \end{aligned} \] Exchanging \(k,l\) yields the analogous equality.

Step 3. Use global symmetry and cancel the scalar

Symmetry of \(D\) identifies the two right-hand sides. Therefore \[ \beta_x\,\kappa_x(k)(l) =\beta_x\,\kappa_x(l)(k). \] Every edge label is a nonzero polynomial, so the finite product \(\beta_x\) is nonzero; for an empty incoming set it is \(1\). The polynomial coefficient algebra is a domain, and cancellation proves \[ \kappa_x(k)(l)=\kappa_x(l)(k). \]

Step 4. Substitute inverse images of functionals

Take \(k=\kappa_x^{-1}(\lambda)\) and \(l=\kappa_x^{-1}(\mu)\). The identities \(\kappa_x(k)=\lambda\) and \(\kappa_x(l)=\mu\) transform Step 3 into the claimed inverse-symmetry formula.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.costalkEquivDual_pairing: PositiveTransfer.lean:24.

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.costalkEquivDual_symmetric: PositiveTransfer.lean:43.

OAI.KLInvariance.BruhatGraph.costalkEquivDual_inverse_symmetric: PositiveTransfer.lean:62.

Used by