Theorem Composition, balance, and grading of adjoints
✓ theorem proved

Composition, balance, and grading of adjoints

Let \(D:M\xrightarrow{\sim}M^*\) be a perfect pairing over a commutative ring \(R\), and define adjoints by \(\langle f^*m,n\rangle=\langle m,fn\rangle\). Composition is written \(fg=f\circ g\). Then \[ (fg)^*=g^*f^*,\qquad 0^*=0. \] In particular, \(f^2=f\) implies \((f^*)^2=f^*\).

If the pairing is symmetric, then \[ \langle m,f^*n\rangle=\langle fm,n\rangle,\qquad (f^*)^*=f. \] If an operator \(t\) is balanced, meaning \(\langle tm,n\rangle=\langle m,tn\rangle\), and \(ft=tf\), then \(f^*t=tf^*\).

Finally suppose \(R=A\) is a graded algebra over a field, \(M\) has an integer grading, and \(\langle M_i,M_j\rangle\subseteq A_{i+j-L}\). If \(f\) preserves degrees, then \(f^*\) preserves degrees.

Proof

Step 1. Detect equality by pairing

If \(\langle u,n\rangle=\langle v,n\rangle\) for every \(n\), then \(D(u)=D(v)\). Injectivity of \(D\) gives \(u=v\). We use this test for the operator identities.

Step 2. Reverse a composition

For arbitrary \(m,n\), \[ \begin{aligned} \langle(fg)^*m,n\rangle &=\langle m,f(gn)\rangle\\ &=\langle f^*m,gn\rangle\\ &=\langle g^*f^*m,n\rangle. \end{aligned} \] Step 1 proves \((fg)^*=g^*f^*\). Likewise \(\langle0^*m,n\rangle=\langle m,0\rangle=0\), so \(0^*=0\). Taking \(g=f\) and \(f^2=f\) gives \((f^*)^2=(f^2)^*=f^*\).

Step 3. Use symmetry for the double adjoint

Symmetry and the adjoint equation yield \[ \langle m,f^*n\rangle =\langle f^*n,m\rangle =\langle n,fm\rangle =\langle fm,n\rangle. \] Consequently \[ \langle(f^*)^*m,n\rangle=\langle m,f^*n\rangle=\langle fm,n\rangle. \] Step 1 gives \((f^*)^*=f\).

Step 4. Transport commutation with a balanced operator

For every \(m,n\), \[ \begin{aligned} \langle f^*tm,n\rangle &=\langle tm,fn\rangle\\ &=\langle m,tfn\rangle\\ &=\langle m,ftn\rangle\\ &=\langle f^*m,tn\rangle\\ &=\langle tf^*m,n\rangle. \end{aligned} \] The second and last equalities use balance, and the middle equality uses \(tf=ft\). Step 1 proves commutation of \(f^*\) and \(t\).

Step 5. Recover the adjoint's degree from its functional

Let \(m\in M_n\). The functional \(\lambda(v)=\langle m,fv\rangle\) sends \(M_j\) into \(A_{n+j-L}\), because \(f\) preserves degrees. In the convention \(\lambda(M_j)\subseteq A_{j+r}\), it has degree \(r=n-L\).

The homogeneous-representative theorem therefore gives \[ f^*m=D^{-1}(\lambda)\in M_{(n-L)+L}=M_n. \] This proves degree preservation.

References

The local source declarations below give the constructions and proofs.

Lean formalization

OAI.PerfectAdjoint.adjoint_comp: IntegralPairings.lean:2228.

OAI.PerfectAdjoint.adjoint_idempotent: IntegralPairings.lean:2238.

OAI.PerfectAdjoint.commutes_of_balanced: IntegralPairings.lean:2245.

OAI.PerfectAdjoint.symmetric_pairing: IntegralPairings.lean:2253.

OAI.PerfectAdjoint.adjoint_adjoint: IntegralPairings.lean:2257.

OAI.PerfectAdjoint.adjoint_zero: BalancedPairings.lean:1691.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.adjoint_homogeneous: IntegralPairings.lean:2340.

Used by