Perfect graded pairings and support orthogonality
Let \(B\) be a graded sheaf over a graded commutative algebra \(A\), and let \(\Gamma=\Gamma(B)\) be its global section module. Fix an integer \(d\). A perfect graded section pairing consists of an \(A\)-linear isomorphism \[ D:\Gamma\xrightarrow{\sim}\Gamma^*, \qquad \langle m,n\rangle=D(m)(n), \] with a homogeneity condition and two support conditions.
Perfection means that every \(A\)-linear functional on \(\Gamma\) is pairing against a unique first argument. Homogeneity says that if \(m_x\in B^x_i\) and \(n_x\in B^x_j\) at every vertex, then \[ \langle m,n\rangle\in A_{i+j-d}. \] Here a homogeneous section means a section homogeneous of the same degree at every coordinate.
The support conditions are \[ \begin{aligned} m\in\Gamma_{\{x\}},\ n_x=0&\ \Longrightarrow\ \langle m,n\rangle=0,\\ m_x=0,\ n\in\Gamma_{\{x\}}&\ \Longrightarrow\ \langle m,n\rangle=0. \end{aligned} \] They let a supported first argument define a functional of the second argument's \(x\)-coordinate, and a supported second argument define a functional of the first argument's \(x\)-coordinate.
A symmetric perfect section pairing adds \[ \langle m,n\rangle=\langle n,m\rangle. \] Symmetry exchanges the two support equations. The graded perfect-pairing data record both equations explicitly.
A complete one-edge calculation
Use the congruence sheaf over \(A=\mathbb R[\alpha]\): \[ \Gamma=\{(f,g)\in A^2:f-g\in\alpha A\}. \] Set \(u=(f+g)/2\) and \(v=(f-g)/(2\alpha)\). Both lie in \(A\), and \[ (f,g)=u(1,1)+v(\alpha,-\alpha). \] This gives a basis \(e_0=(1,1),e_1=(\alpha,-\alpha)\) of degrees zero and one.
Define \[ \langle(f,g),(f',g')\rangle =uv'+vu'=\frac{ff'-gg'}{2\alpha}. \] Expanding \(f=u+\alpha v,\ g=u-\alpha v\) and the primed expressions gives \(ff'-gg'=2\alpha(uv'+vu')\), which proves the quotient is a polynomial.
In the displayed basis, the pairing matrix is \[ \begin{pmatrix}0&1\\ 1&0\end{pmatrix}. \] It squares to the identity, so it is invertible over \(A\); this proves perfection. It is symmetric. For homogeneous input degrees \(i,j\), division by \(\alpha\) lowers the output degree to \(i+j-1\), giving \(d=1\).
A section supported at the lower vertex is \((\alpha h,0)\). Its pairing with \((f,g)\) is \(hf/2\), which vanishes when \(f=0\). At the upper vertex the analogous pairing is \(-hg/2\), which vanishes when \(g=0\). Symmetry supplies the other support condition.
This calculation follows the definitions as a worked example. The word-module and boundary-pairing constructions establish the corresponding data for the sheaves used in the main proof.
Integral cuts and later duality
The two support equations imply the balance equation \[ \langle C_xm,n\rangle=\langle m,C_xn\rangle \] for cuts with a common nonzero scalar over a domain. The proof compares each side, multiplied by that scalar, with \(\langle C_xm,C_xn\rangle\). It is developed in Support orthogonality makes integral cuts balanced.
For the example, the two balanced expressions are \(ff'/2\) for \(x\) and \(-gg'/2\) for \(y\). This is the identity used to recover stalk functionals from supported sections.
References
The source declarations below give the definitions and constructions used here.
Lean formalization
The fields pairing, homogeneous, left_orthogonal, and right_orthogonal encode the isomorphism, its degree, and the two support equations. SymmetricPerfectPairing inherits these through toPerfectPairing and adds symmetric.
OAI.KLInvariance.MomentGraph.GradedSheaf.PerfectPairing: Support.lean:1850.
OAI.KLInvariance.MomentGraph.GradedSheaf.SymmetricPerfectPairing: EdgeLocalization.lean:941.