Theorem Cancelling lower summands in character identities
✓ theorem proved

Cancelling lower summands in character identities

Let the indexing set be finite and let the coefficients lie in a commutative ring. Suppose \(m_t=1\), \[ \sum_y m_yq_y=\sum_z r_z\sum_y m_yp_{y,z}, \] and, for every \(y\ne t\), \[ q_y=\sum_z r_zp_{y,z}. \] Then the same identity holds for \(t\): \[ q_t=\sum_z r_zp_{t,z}. \]

Proof

Step 1. Expand the right-hand side in a fixed order

The hypothesis is \[ \sum_y m_yq_y=\sum_z r_z\left(\sum_y m_yp_{y,z}\right). \] All sums are finite. Distribute multiplication and interchange the summation order: \[ \sum_z\sum_y r_zm_yp_{y,z} =\sum_y m_y\left(\sum_zr_zp_{y,z}\right). \] Only commutativity and finite distributivity are used.

Step 2. Move all terms into one sum

Subtract the expanded right-hand side from the left: \[ 0=\sum_y m_y\left(q_y-\sum_zr_zp_{y,z}\right). \] The displayed identity follows by distributivity in the coefficient ring.

Step 3. Eliminate each lower-index term

For every \(y\ne t\), the lower identity says \(q_y=\sum_zr_zp_{y,z}\). Its parenthesized factor is therefore zero, so that entire summand is zero, regardless of the value of \(m_y\).

The only remaining summand is \(m_t(q_t-\sum_zr_zp_{t,z})\).

Step 4. Use the normalized top multiplicity

The hypothesis \(m_t=1\) changes the last equality to \(q_t-\sum_zr_zp_{t,z}=0\). Add the finite sum to both sides to obtain the conclusion.

The normalization at the top makes this a finite-sum identity over the original commutative ring, so it applies directly to integral character polynomials.

References

2. Real realizations and moment-graph sheaves.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.finite_character_cancellation: DyerPaths.lean:15.

Used by