Theorem A localized scaled-image equality gives an original-module multiplier
✓ theorem proved

A localized scaled-image equality gives an original-module multiplier

Let \(R\) be a commutative ring, \(P\subseteq R\) a multiplicative submonoid, and \(S=P^{-1}R\), with structure map \(\iota:R\to S\). Let \(\mathcal B\) be an \(R\)-linear sheaf on an ordered graph with finitely many edges.

Fix an edge \(e:x\to y\), outgoing selections \(F,H\) at \(x,y\), and \(a\in R\). Write \[ L=\rho_e^-(K_x^{\mathcal B}(F)),\qquad U=\rho_e^+(K_y^{\mathcal B}(H)) \] inside \(\mathcal B^e\). Suppose the scalar-extended sheaf satisfies \[ L_e^{\mathcal B_S}(F)=\iota(a)\,U_e^{\mathcal B_S}(H), \qquad \mathcal B_S=S\otimes_R\mathcal B. \] Then every \(z\in L\) has a multiplier \(s\in P\) such that \[ sz\in aU. \]

Relation to the OpenAI notes

Two denominator factors convert localized membership into a scalar witness.

OpenAI notes: The notes pass from localized image equality to local membership in the free target, using flatness to commute localization with the finite kernel and image constructions. edge:bound, edge:lattice.

Lean (primary): The embedded tensor image is identified with a localized submodule. A numerator denominator and a second factor clearing equality in the localized module give an original-module scalar witness. The sheaf application verifies flat lower/upper image identities and compatibility of the scalar map on pure tensors before applying this lemma. TerminalKernels:909, TerminalKernels:914, TerminalKernels:946.

Role in the proof: The Blueprint displays both denominator factors and explains the exact transition from an equality of localized edge images to a multiplier outside the plane prime.

Proof

Step 1. Put the original lower image into its localized image

A localization is flat. On the finite graph, the flat kernel-and-image theorem identifies the embedded scalar extension of \(L\) with \(L_e^{\mathcal B_S}(F)\), and that of \(U\) with \(U_e^{\mathcal B_S}(H)\).

Since \(z\in L\), the pure tensor \(1\otimes z\) belongs to the embedded scalar extension of \(L\), hence to the localized lower image.

Step 2. Use the localized equality with an actual upper witness

By the assumed equality, there is a vector \(w\in K_y^{\mathcal B_S}(H)\) such that \[ 1\otimes z=\iota(a)\rho_e^{\mathcal B_S,+}(w). \] Thus \(1\otimes z\) lies in \(\iota(a)\) times the localized upper image.

Step 3. Identify this scaled image with the scalar extension of aU

Let \(\mu_a:\mathcal B^e\to\mathcal B^e\) be multiplication by \(a\). Scalar extension sends it to multiplication by \(\iota(a)\). On pure tensors, \[ (\mu_a)_S(r\otimes v)=r\otimes av =\iota(a)(r\otimes v), \] and linearity extends the equality to every tensor.

The embedded-image scalar-extension identity therefore gives \[ (aU)_S=\iota(a)U_S =\iota(a)U_e^{\mathcal B_S}(H). \] Together with Step 2, this proves \(1\otimes z\in(aU)_S\).

Step 4. Clear a denominator in the actual edge module

Apply the tensor-localization denominator theorem to the original submodule \(aU\subseteq\mathcal B^e\) and the vector \(z\). It supplies \(s\in P\) with \(sz\in aU\), proving the claim.

For localization at a prime ideal \(\mathfrak p\), this says \(s\notin\mathfrak p\). It is the form used to turn a plane-local image equality into a multiplier outside the plane prime.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.MomentGraph.Sheaf.scaledImages_denominator: TerminalKernels.lean:946.

Used by