Theorem Character reflection from a homogeneous dual equivalence
✓ theorem proved

Character reflection from a homogeneous dual equivalence

Let \(A=k[X_1,\ldots,X_N]\), with \(k\) a field and each variable in degree one. Let \(M,N'\) be finitely generated, nonnegatively graded \(A\)-modules, and assume \(M\) is free. Suppose \[ e:\operatorname{Hom}_A(M,A)\xrightarrow{\sim}N' \] is an \(A\)-linear equivalence. Let \(D\in\mathbb N\), and assume that for every homogeneous functional \(\lambda\) of degree \(r\), \[ \lambda(M_j)\subseteq A_{j+r}\quad(j\in\mathbb Z) \quad\Longrightarrow\quad e(\lambda)\in N'_{r+D}. \]

Then \(N'\) is free. For a finite nonnegative homogeneous basis \((b_i)\) of \(M\), with degrees \(d_i\), the vectors \(e(b_i^*)\) form a homogeneous basis of \(N'\) of degrees \(D-d_i\), and \(d_i\le D\). Consequently \[ \operatorname{natDegree}\operatorname{ch}(M;q)\le D,\qquad \operatorname{ch}(N';q)=\operatorname{reflect}_D\operatorname{ch}(M;q). \]

Proof

Step 1. Transport the dual basis

Choose the nonnegative homogeneous basis \((b_i)\) supplied by the basis theorem. Its coordinate functionals form a basis \((b_i^*)\) of the \(A\)-linear dual. Each satisfies \[ b_i^*(M_j)\subseteq A_{j-d_i}, \] so its functional degree is \(-d_i\).

The linear equivalence \(e\) transports this basis to \[ c_i=e(b_i^*). \] Thus \((c_i)\) is a finite free basis of \(N'\). The homogeneity hypothesis gives \(c_i\in N'_{D-d_i}\), interpreting this difference first as an integer.

Step 2. Prove the bound on every basis degree

The functional \(b_i^*\) is nonzero because \(b_i^*(b_i)=1\). Injectivity of \(e\) therefore makes \(c_i\ne0\).

If \(d_i>D\), then \(D-d_i<0\). Nonnegativity of \(N'\) would give \(N'_{D-d_i}=0\), contradicting \(c_i\ne0\). Hence \(d_i\le D\).

The integer degree \(D-d_i\) is therefore the same as the natural-number subtraction used in the source. This is degree_le_of_dual_equiv.

Step 3. Construct the reflected nonnegative basis

Use the old finite index set, the transported dual basis \(c_i\), and the degrees \(D-d_i\in\mathbb N\). Step 2 and the given homogeneity equation verify every degree condition. These data are the source's reflectedBasis construction.

Its polynomial is \[ \sum_iq^{D-d_i}. \] Basis independence identifies this with the character of \(N'\). The same theorem gives \(\operatorname{ch}(M;q)=\sum_iq^{d_i}\).

Step 4. Identify the polynomial reflection and degree bound

Every \(d_i\le D\), so polynomial reflection sends \(q^{d_i}\) to \(q^{D-d_i}\). Reflection preserves finite sums, hence \[ \operatorname{reflect}_D\left(\sum_iq^{d_i}\right) =\sum_iq^{D-d_i} =\operatorname{ch}(N';q). \] The same bound on the summand exponents gives \(\operatorname{natDegree}\operatorname{ch}(M;q)\le D\). For a zero module, the basis sum is zero and Lean's convention \(\operatorname{natDegree}(0)=0\) satisfies this bound as well.

At an invertible parameter, the reflected character evaluates as \(q^D\operatorname{ch}(M;q^{-1})\). The displayed degree bound is what identifies that expression with polynomial reflection.

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.degree_le_of_dual_equiv: Support.lean:747.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.reflectedBasis: Support.lean:763.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.char_of_dual_equiv: Support.lean:784.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.char_natDegree_le_of_dual_equiv: CharacterReciprocity.lean:1053.

Used by