A free cover splits into a minimal cover and a graded free remainder
Let \(A\) be a connected nonnegatively graded Noetherian domain. Let \[ \pi:P\twoheadrightarrow T \] be a minimal graded free cover, and let \(f:F\twoheadrightarrow T\) be any degree-zero surjection from a finite nonnegative graded free module.
There are degree-zero maps \(g:F\to P\), \(h:P\to F\) with \[ \pi g=f,\qquad gh=1_P. \] For \(K=\ker g\), there is a graded isomorphism \[ F\xrightarrow{\sim}P\oplus K,\qquad v\longmapsto(gv,\ v-hgv), \] and \(K\) is finite graded free. Under this isomorphism, \(f\) is the map \((p,k)\mapsto\pi(p)\).
Relation to the OpenAI notes
Related descent in different coefficient settings.
OpenAI notes: The plane-localization proposition descends through a finite coset graph over an ungraded local ring. Nakayama makes the lifted stalk map surjective, its free target gives a splitting, and projectivity over the local ring makes the remainder free. Multiplicities count copies of local structure models. loc:decomposition.
Lean (primary): The graded construction lifts in both directions and corrects the composite using invertibility modulo the positive ideal. The remainder is graded projective over a connected Noetherian domain and has a homogeneous basis. Its degrees determine nonnegative shifts of boundary models. Partial isomorphisms already include every edge whose upper endpoint has been processed. SheafMorphisms:1427, SheafMorphisms:1567, SheafMorphisms:1642.
Role in the proof: Both constructions split a stalk over the upper boundary image and add models centered at the new vertex. The graded construction records a polynomial of shifts at each center; the ungraded local construction records an integer number of copies.
Proof
Step 1. Lift in both directions
Homogeneous lifting gives \(g:F\to P\) with \(\pi g=f\), using freeness of \(F\). Applying the same theorem to the surjection \(f\) and the free source \(P\) gives \(h_0:P\to F\) with \(f h_0=\pi\).
Put \(u=gh_0:P\to P\). For \(p\in P\), \[ \pi(p-u(p))=\pi(p)-f(h_0(p))=0. \] Minimality gives \(p-u(p)\in\ker\pi\subseteq JP\).
Step 2. Correct the lift to a section
The map \(u\) is degree zero and induces the identity modulo \(J\). The identity-modulo-positive-ideal theorem makes it a graded automorphism.
Set \(h=h_0u^{-1}\). Then \(gh=gh_0u^{-1}=uu^{-1}=1_P\). Also \[ fh=\pi gh=\pi. \]
Step 3. Construct the decomposition and check its inverse
For \(v\in F\), \[ g(v-hgv)=gv-ghgv=0, \] so the second component lies in \(K\). Define \[ E(v)=(gv,v-hgv),\qquad E^{-1}(p,k)=hp+k. \] The first composite is \[ E^{-1}(E(v))=hgv+v-hgv=v. \] For \(k\in K\), \(gk=0\), so \[ E(hp+k)=(p,hp+k-hp)=(p,k). \] Both maps preserve degree because \(g,h\) do and the kernel has its induced grading.
Finally \(f(v)=\pi(gv)\). Thus in the new coordinates, \(f(p,k)=\pi(p)\).
Step 4. Prove projectivity and graded freeness of the remainder
The map \(q:F\to K\), \(q(v)=v-hgv\), restricts to the identity on \(K\). Hence \(K\) is a direct summand of \(F\).
To see projectivity, take a map \(a:K\to Y\) and a surjection \(X\to Y\). Extend \(a\) to \(F\) by composing with \(q\). A map from the free module \(F\) lifts by choosing preimages of its basis values. Restricting that lift to \(K\) proves the required lifting property.
The kernel is finite because \(A\) is Noetherian and \(F\) is finite. It is nonnegatively graded, as a homogeneous submodule of \(F\). The graded projective-to-free theorem supplies a finite homogeneous basis. Every basis degree is nonnegative because its nonzero vector lies in the nonnegative module \(K\).
Step 5. Compute a cover with an extra degree-two generator
Take \(A=\mathbb R[\alpha]\), \(T=A/(\alpha)\), \(P=A\), and \(F=A\oplus A(2)\). Let \[ \pi(p)=p\bmod\alpha,\qquad f(u,v)=u\bmod\alpha. \] Choose \(g(u,v)=u\) and \(h(p)=(p,0)\). Then \[ K=0\oplus A(2),\qquad E(u,v)=(u,(0,v)). \] The cover kernel is \(\alpha A\oplus A(2)\), while the remainder \(K\) records the additional free generator beyond the minimal cover.
References
The local source declarations below give the constructions and proofs.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.exists_minimalCover_split: SheafMorphisms.lean:1427.
OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.Hom.splitEquiv: SheafMorphisms.lean:1445.
OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.Hom.splitEquiv_graded: SheafMorphisms.lean:1450.
OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.Hom.kernel_free_of_split: SheafMorphisms.lean:1459.