Theorem Isomorphisms determined by maps of minimal covers
✓ theorem proved

Isomorphisms determined by maps of minimal covers

Let \(A\) be a connected nonnegatively graded Noetherian domain over a field. Put \(J=A_{>0}\), and let all modules below be finite and nonnegatively graded.

Suppose \[ \pi:F\twoheadrightarrow T,\qquad \rho:G\twoheadrightarrow T \] are minimal graded free covers. Thus \(F,G\) are free, the maps preserve degree, and \[ \ker\pi\subseteq JF,\qquad \ker\rho\subseteq JG. \] If a degree-zero map \(f:F\to G\) satisfies \(\rho f=\pi\), then \(f\) is a graded isomorphism. Consequently any two minimal graded free covers of \(T\) are isomorphic by a map commuting with their projections.

There is also a version for a specified automorphism of the covered module: if \(a:T\xrightarrow{\sim}T\) preserves degree and \(f:F\to F\) satisfies \(\pi f=a\pi\), then \(f\) is a graded automorphism.

Proof

Step 1. Lift a map in the reverse direction

For the first statement, use the homogeneous lifting theorem with the free source \(G\), the surjection \(\pi:F\to T\), and the map \(\rho:G\to T\). It produces a degree-zero map \(g:G\to F\) with \[ \pi g=\rho. \]

Step 2. Compare both composites with the identity

For \(v\in F\), \[ \pi(v-gf(v))=\pi(v)-\rho(f(v))=0, \] using \(\pi g=\rho\) and \(\rho f=\pi\). Hence \(v-gf(v)\in\ker\pi\subseteq JF\).

For \(w\in G\), \[ \rho(w-fg(w))=\rho(w)-\pi(g(w))=0, \] so \(w-fg(w)\in\ker\rho\subseteq JG\).

Both \(gf\) and \(fg\) therefore induce the identity modulo the positive ideal. The identity-modulo-positive-ideal theorem makes them bijective.

Step 3. Deduce bijectivity of the specified map

If \(f(v)=0\), then \(gf(v)=0\), and injectivity of \(gf\) gives \(v=0\). Thus \(f\) is injective.

Given \(w\in G\), surjectivity of \(fg\) gives a \(w'\in G\) with \(fg(w')=w\). Then \(v=g(w')\) satisfies \(f(v)=w\). Thus \(f\) is surjective.

A bijective degree-zero linear map has a degree-zero inverse by the homogeneous-component argument, so \(f\) is a graded isomorphism.

Step 4. Cover an automorphism of the target

For the second statement, the inverse \(a^{-1}\) preserves degree: decompose a preimage into homogeneous components and use injectivity of \(a\), exactly as for \(f^{-1}\) in Step 3.

Lift the map \(a^{-1}\pi:F\to T\) through \(\pi\), obtaining a degree-zero \(l:F\to F\) with \(\pi l=a^{-1}\pi\). Then \[ \pi fl=a\pi l=aa^{-1}\pi=\pi,\qquad \pi lf=a^{-1}\pi f=a^{-1}a\pi=\pi. \] Consequently \(1-fl\) and \(1-lf\) have images in \(\ker\pi\subseteq JF\). The identity-modulo-positive-ideal theorem makes both composites bijective. Injectivity of \(lf\) and surjectivity of \(fl\) give bijectivity of \(f\), as in Step 3.

Step 5. Construct a comparison between any two covers

Use the homogeneous lifting theorem with the free source \(F\), the surjection \(\rho:G\to T\), and the map \(\pi:F\to T\). It gives a degree-zero \(f:F\to G\) with \(\rho f=\pi\). Steps 1–3 prove that this comparison is an isomorphism.

References

The source declarations below give the constructions and proofs.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.MinimalCover.hom_bijective: EdgeLocalization.lean:482.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.MinimalCover.bijective_of_boundaryIso: SheafMorphisms.lean:1171.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.ModuleData.MinimalCover.equiv: GradedModules.lean:1422.

Used by