Theorem Positive-ideal coordinates and strict diagonal degree
✓ theorem proved

Positive-ideal coordinates and strict diagonal degree

Let \(k\) be a field and \(A=\bigoplus_{n\in\mathbb Z}A_n\) a commutative graded \(k\)-algebra, with \(A_n=0\) for \(n<0\). Let \(M=\bigoplus_nM_n\) be a graded \(A\)-module with a finite homogeneous \(A\)-basis \((m_i)\), where \(m_i\in M_{d_i}\) and \(d_i\in\mathbb Z\). Write \(\lambda_i=m_i^*\) for its dual basis.

Suppose \(D\in\mathbb Z\) and an \(A\)-linear map \[ Q:\operatorname{Hom}_A(M,A)\longrightarrow M \] satisfy \[ Q(\lambda_i)\in M_{D-d_i}\quad\text{for every }i, \qquad \operatorname{im}Q\subseteq A_+M. \] For a specified index \(i\), the hypothesis \[ a_{ii}:=\lambda_i(Q(\lambda_i))\ne0 \] implies \[ 2d_i<D. \]

Proof

Step 1. Evaluate an ideal multiple by a linear functional

For any ideal \(J\subseteq A\), a vector \(v\in JM\) is a finite sum \[ v=\sum_r a_rv_r,\qquad a_r\in J,\quad v_r\in M. \] An \(A\)-linear functional \(f\) gives \[ f(v)=\sum_r a_rf(v_r). \] Each term lies in \(J\), and \(J\) is closed under addition. Hence \(f(v)\in J\). This is the source's dual_mem_ideal.

In particular, \(Q(\lambda_i)\in A_+M\) implies \(a_{ii}\in A_+\).

Step 2. Compute the homogeneous degree of a coordinate

The dual-basis degree theorem says \[ \lambda_i(M_n)\subseteq A_{n-d_i}. \] Apply it to \(Q(\lambda_i)\in M_{D-d_i}\): \[ a_{ii}\in A_{D-d_i-d_i}=A_{D-2d_i}. \]

More generally, the matrix coefficient \(a_{ij}=\lambda_i(Q(\lambda_j))\) lies in \(A_{D-d_j-d_i}\), and Step 1 puts it in \(A_+\). This follows from the same coordinate calculation.

Step 3. Detect positive degree

Let \(a\ne0\) be homogeneous of degree \(n\) and belong to \(A_+\). If \(n<0\), then \(A_n=0\), contradicting \(a\ne0\).

If \(n=0\), the augmentation is the degree-zero projection, so \(\epsilon(a)=a\). But the augmentation-kernel theorem gives \(A_+=\ker\epsilon\), hence \(\epsilon(a)=0\), again a contradiction.

Thus \(n>0\). This is homogeneous_positive_nonzero.

Step 4. Apply positivity to the diagonal coefficient

The specified \(a_{ii}\) is nonzero by hypothesis, homogeneous of degree \(D-2d_i\) by Step 2, and in \(A_+\) by Step 1. Step 3 gives \[ D-2d_i>0. \] Rearranging proves \(2d_i<D\).

Step 5. Calculate a rank-one example

As an illustrative graded-module calculation, take \(A=k[\alpha]\), \(\deg\alpha=1\), \(M=Ae\) with \(\deg e=r\in\mathbb Z\), and let \(\lambda(e)=1\). Choose \[ Q(\lambda)=\alpha^s e,\qquad s\in\mathbb N,\ s>0. \] Its image is contained in \(A_+M\). The homogeneity condition has \(D=2r+s\), since \(Q(\lambda)\) has degree \(r+s=D-r\). The diagonal coefficient is \(\alpha^s\), and the conclusion is \(2r<2r+s\).

References

The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.

Lean formalization

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.homogeneous_positive_nonzero: EdgeLocalization.lean:1043.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.dual_mem_ideal: EdgeLocalization.lean:1060.

OAI.KLInvariance.Graded.local_diagonal_strict_degree: EdgeLocalization.lean:1077.

Used by