Degreewise quotient defects of a subspace inclusion
Fix ambient homogeneous pieces \(M_n\) and subspaces \(S,T\subseteq M\). Write \[ S_n=S\cap M_n,\qquad T_n=T\cap M_n. \] The source's degree-\(n\) defect space is \[ D_n=T_n/(S_n\cap T_n), \] where the denominator is viewed as a subspace of \(T_n\).
For an inclusion \(S\subseteq T\), this simplifies to \[ D_n=T_n/S_n. \] When \(S,T\) are homogeneous, these are the degree pieces of the quotient \(T/S\).
Weighted defect terms
For finite-dimensional pieces and a positive real parameter \(q\), define \[ \operatorname{defectTerm}(S,T;q,n)=\dim_k(D_n)q^n. \] The dimension is a nonnegative integer, and \(q^n>0\). A nonzero defect space therefore gives a strictly positive term.
For \(S\subseteq T\), the finite-dimensional quotient formula gives \[ \dim_kD_n=\dim_kT_n-\dim_kS_n. \] The defect theorem proves convergence of its weighted series from convergence of the larger Hilbert series, then identifies \[ \sum_n\dim_kD_nq^n=H_T(q)-H_S(q). \]
A defect concentrated in degree zero
Let \(A=k[X,Y]\), \(T=A\), and \(S=(X,Y)\). Every positive-degree monomial belongs to \(S\), while the constant \(1\) does not. Hence \[ D_0=k,\qquad D_n=0\quad(n\ne0). \] The defect value is one at every positive \(q\).
The Hilbert values are \[ H_T(q)=\frac1{(1-q)^2},\qquad H_S(q)=\frac1{(1-q)^2}-1 \quad(0<q<1). \] This example records exactly the missing constant component.
References
The local source declarations below give the construction and proof.
Lean formalization
OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.defectPiece: ModuleAlgebra.lean:571.
OAI.KLInvariance.Hilbert.defectTerm: ModuleAlgebra.lean:574.